Helpful Score: 7
I'm sad to say it, but this is probably one of the worst books I've ever read. The plot is non existent, the characters thin, and it is full of inconsistencies. I think this will be my last Churchill. I don't know what happened to her.
Kerry K. (mistysmere) -
Helpful Score: 5
Jane and Mel get married!!!!! Finally. Quite honestly, this book was very light on mystery. It almost felt like the author felt she had to tie up loose ends before she felt comfortable moving aways from this group of characters.
Even without all the mystery, I found this book to be enthralling. Things that I wanted to happen books ago did. But it also meant that some sad things had to happen as well. I've come to love this family, so it was a little sad to think this might be the end. If there is never another book in this series, I feel satisfied. If there is another book in this series, I will be delighted. But I wonder if the author will do some spin offs....
Even without all the mystery, I found this book to be enthralling. Things that I wanted to happen books ago did. But it also meant that some sad things had to happen as well. I've come to love this family, so it was a little sad to think this might be the end. If there is never another book in this series, I feel satisfied. If there is another book in this series, I will be delighted. But I wonder if the author will do some spin offs....
Charlene V. (Workmom1) reviewed The Accidental Florist (Jane Jeffry, Bk 16) on + 151 more book reviews
Helpful Score: 4
I have like all of Jill Churchill's Jane Jeffry's mysteries but I am disappointed in this one. It just isn't up to the rest of them. I think maybe she should just wait a bit for the next one to really get back to the fun of these stories.
Helpful Score: 3
Although I've really enjoyed previous Jane Jeffry "mysteries," this was a disappointment. The mystery element was almost completely absent while the book focused on extraneous matters, Jane's book, wedding, and family relationships. While these are part and parcel of her life, as a mystery series, I expect more mystery and in this book, it seemed like an afterthought and certainly wasn't compelling.
Stephanie S. (punkinema) -
Helpful Score: 2
Very disappointing Jane Jeffry book.....no real mystery and dull and boring. Sorry I ordered it.
I have read all the the Jane Jeffry series and this was by far the worst one. Jane was a cranky bridezilla in this book and she and her friend were only just barely involved in solving the murder. She has always been a likeable character before and I have really liked all the books--except this one!
Helpful Score: 1
Completely dissapointed. There was no real mystery here, and very little interaction between Jane and Shelly. The clearing up family matters was horrendous, and she plugs her Grace & Favor series by having Jane by the newest one!
She really should have stopped 4 books back, this series just lost all of its zing, and I only read til the end because it started out so well. Read it so you can say you read them all and then swap it as I have done.
She really should have stopped 4 books back, this series just lost all of its zing, and I only read til the end because it started out so well. Read it so you can say you read them all and then swap it as I have done.
Helpful Score: 1
I once loved the Jane Jeffry Mysteries but this one is far from being a mystery and even if read as a "Novel" it is bad.
Not the best, by far. Story centers around Jane and the life changes that are happening; not much mystery. The mystery seems to have been almost forgotten. Is Ms Churchhill getting tired of writting about Jane?? Seems like it to me. Sorry to see her go.
Marci K. (ontheroad19) reviewed The Accidental Florist (Jane Jeffry, Bk 16) on + 23 more book reviews
Helpful Score: 1
Not really a mystery, as the story really revolves around Jane's life and the changes that are going on. The mystery is really the second story line, and not the main theme.
Jane is finally getting married to detective Van Dyne, and she and Shelly spend a lot of time finding the right fabrics, hats and flowers for the fake wedding to be thrown by Mel's mother. Meanwhile her deceased husband's mother tries to play havoc with the whole thing. Jane's children are almost all grown, so we have seen their development, and we get to meet her parents, too. It is more of a Jane story than a mystery.
I disliked the previous couple of books, but decided to give the series one last try. Well ... that was it. Jane's fantastically successful, rich, and now married. What's left? Yawn.
Lila D. (readingrocks) reviewed The Accidental Florist (Jane Jeffry, Bk 16) on + 10 more book reviews
This was truely one of the worst books I have ever read. I kept waiting for it to get to the good part and it never happened. A couple hours of my life wasted.
I started reading the Jane Jeffry books when the very first one was published. And although I always enjoyed dipping into the Jane and Shelly world - the mysteries have been getting less and less compelling.
Unfortunately, this last installment, did not truly have a mystery that Jane was involved in at all. While it was nice to have the story of Jane come to some closure, the book was pretty much devoid of plot, contained MANY inconsistencies with things established earlier in the series and felt like Jill Churchill was writing out of contractual obligation rather than because she had a story to tell.
Unfortunately, this last installment, did not truly have a mystery that Jane was involved in at all. While it was nice to have the story of Jane come to some closure, the book was pretty much devoid of plot, contained MANY inconsistencies with things established earlier in the series and felt like Jill Churchill was writing out of contractual obligation rather than because she had a story to tell.
Surburban supersleuth Jane Jeffry and Detective Mel VanDyne have finally decided to get married, but they're going to have to fight off Jane's new mother-in-law and find a killer along the way down the aisle. The Jan Jeffry books are always worth the read, nice and cozy, laced with subtle humor and a good plot.
Silly mystery
Sandra S. (kattkatt99) reviewed The Accidental Florist (Jane Jeffry, Bk 16) on + 119 more book reviews
Found while searching on line...
Jane Jeffry and longtime beau Detective Mel VanDyne finally decide to marry, but Mel's overbearing mother wants to take charge of not only the rehearsal dinner but the actual wedding. Since Jane half expected Mel's mother to steamroll the entire event, she agreesâbut with rules of her own. No bridesmaids, no groomsmen. And she can't tell Jane what to wear.
But during what should have been a blissful interval between the engagement and the bouquet toss, several other occurrences take place. Mel convinces Jane and her best friend, Shelley Nowack, to take a women's safety class. They learn a lot, but the class is cut short when a dead body is discovered. So between Jane's wedding planning, her new writing project, and a battle between both mother-in-laws, a murderer must be found before this bride can walk happily down the aisle.
Jane Jeffry and longtime beau Detective Mel VanDyne finally decide to marry, but Mel's overbearing mother wants to take charge of not only the rehearsal dinner but the actual wedding. Since Jane half expected Mel's mother to steamroll the entire event, she agreesâbut with rules of her own. No bridesmaids, no groomsmen. And she can't tell Jane what to wear.
But during what should have been a blissful interval between the engagement and the bouquet toss, several other occurrences take place. Mel convinces Jane and her best friend, Shelley Nowack, to take a women's safety class. They learn a lot, but the class is cut short when a dead body is discovered. So between Jane's wedding planning, her new writing project, and a battle between both mother-in-laws, a murderer must be found before this bride can walk happily down the aisle.
Good Book
