Rosanne G. (GratefulGracie) reviewed Amazing Grace: William Wilberforce and the Heroic Campaign to End Slavery on + 15 more book reviews
Moving, powerful book about a humble man who changed the mindset of the world regarding slavery.
Alex V. (Allypally) reviewed Amazing Grace: William Wilberforce and the Heroic Campaign to End Slavery on + 15 more book reviews
I was really disappointed with this book.
This purports to be a historical biography, but there was not a footnote or bibliographical reference in sight. That, combined with the author's tendency to assert what people were thinking without referencing anything but his own imagination, made me leery of the whole thing.
The author also had a wildy idiosyncratic writing style, and the book was full of over-stuffed and exaggerated similes that made it almost unreadable at times. For instance, in describing Wilberforce's coach journey through France with a friend who was instrumental in his conversion, Metaxas writes that they were 'sailing in their horse-drawn coach through the mountains, like something out of a fairytale, one in which a gnome and a giant on a journey in a sphere of glass and silver discover the Well at the World's End, and drinking a draught of therefrom learn the secret meaning at the heart of the universe.' What??? In describing one of the parliamentary debates on abolition, an opponent proposed a compromise and suggested gradual abolition, which Metaxas asserts was a suggestion 'from the dead belly of hell itself.' The book is full of other such gems that for me at least were very distracting and just plain annoying, especially when combined with the author's tendency to flip-flop between writing in the past and present tense for no apparent reason.
The book is also billed as a companion volume to the movie (which was great) however, it skips over all the parliamentary sneaking and strategising they had to do to get their bill through. This isn't mentioned in the book at all. Not once. Instead Metaxas presents the passing of the abolition bill in 1807 as the triumphant and inevitable conclusion to a long campaign, without even mentioning their brilliant tactics of the year before which resulted in the passing of the Foreign Slave Trade Act, which was one of the high points of the movie.
There is a great story to be told about William Wilberforce, but sadly Eric Metaxas did not manage to do it.
This purports to be a historical biography, but there was not a footnote or bibliographical reference in sight. That, combined with the author's tendency to assert what people were thinking without referencing anything but his own imagination, made me leery of the whole thing.
The author also had a wildy idiosyncratic writing style, and the book was full of over-stuffed and exaggerated similes that made it almost unreadable at times. For instance, in describing Wilberforce's coach journey through France with a friend who was instrumental in his conversion, Metaxas writes that they were 'sailing in their horse-drawn coach through the mountains, like something out of a fairytale, one in which a gnome and a giant on a journey in a sphere of glass and silver discover the Well at the World's End, and drinking a draught of therefrom learn the secret meaning at the heart of the universe.' What??? In describing one of the parliamentary debates on abolition, an opponent proposed a compromise and suggested gradual abolition, which Metaxas asserts was a suggestion 'from the dead belly of hell itself.' The book is full of other such gems that for me at least were very distracting and just plain annoying, especially when combined with the author's tendency to flip-flop between writing in the past and present tense for no apparent reason.
The book is also billed as a companion volume to the movie (which was great) however, it skips over all the parliamentary sneaking and strategising they had to do to get their bill through. This isn't mentioned in the book at all. Not once. Instead Metaxas presents the passing of the abolition bill in 1807 as the triumphant and inevitable conclusion to a long campaign, without even mentioning their brilliant tactics of the year before which resulted in the passing of the Foreign Slave Trade Act, which was one of the high points of the movie.
There is a great story to be told about William Wilberforce, but sadly Eric Metaxas did not manage to do it.
Pamela C. (pammalamma) reviewed Amazing Grace: William Wilberforce and the Heroic Campaign to End Slavery on + 5 more book reviews
I highly recommend this book to anyone who needs inspiration to "fight the good fight."
In William Wilberforce, I feel that I've found a kindred soul: one who sought to fight evil in spite of his health, in spite of the hatred of the world directed at him for "forcing his religious beliefs on others," in spite of cultural stigmata against all his beliefs and even who he was. It really inspired me to fight the evil that I see in our world, and gave me ideas on how success could be achieved, and how long it will most likely take to see change.
Eric Metaxas, the author, focused mainly on the man himself and his fight against slavery. Unlike the movie, there is less of a storyline, but the main events of his life are all there: election to parliament, conversion, marriage, children, illness, and so on. The political situation in England is described in much greater detail than in the movie, as is Wilberforce's conversion. Metaxas accomplishes his history with a lot of wit, to his credit. I laughed out loud several times while reading it, and some parts warranted an immediate, "Honey, you have to read this part" by my husband.
From his childhood, Wilberforce always showed remarkable compassion and sensitivity. Though his parents were nominal Christians at best (the norm for English people of the day) Wilberforce had the blessing, at a young age, to become a foster child in the home of some extended family who were Methodists.
To understand Wilberforce's upbringing, we must also understand the connotation of the word "Methodist" to Wilberforce's contemporaries. To explain that attitude, we have to remember the fallout of the Reformation and the Counter-Reformation, and all the bloodshed and burnings that resulted. With some of these events less than 200 years in the past, the prevailing attitude about religion was that it was dangerous. Everyone pretty much believed that we all have to take our religion lightly, and just go to church, and not get too excited about it, because "we all know" what happens when people get too excited about religion. English churches were boring, and didn't attempt to be anything else.
George Whitefield, a Methodist preacher without a pulpit who was cross-eyed and preached in the fields, had unusual religious fervor at this time, and it was contagious. Because of the Methodists' emotional fervor and disregard for conventional restraint, the term "Methodist" quickly came to be almost synonymous with "religious wacko." The term "fundamentalist" is comparable, today, in its connotation.
It was in this house of Methodist relatives that William first became interested in Christianity, and showed every sign of turning from his parents' life of frivolity and carnality to an austere spiritual life. But, his mother, seeing the change in her son, soon put an end to that, by bringing him home to be "cultured" by attending the opera and theater.
From the book, "Wilberforce was one of the brightest, wittiest, best connected, and generally talented men of his day, someone who might well have become prime minister of Great Britain if he had, in the words of one historian, 'preferred the party to mankind.' But his accomplishments far transcend any mere political victory. Wilberforce can be pictured as standing as a kind of hinge in the middle of history: he pulled the world around a corner, and we can't even look back to see where we've come from."
It wasn't until after Wilberforce was elected to parliament and some conversations with a very thoughtful and spiritual friend that he began to return to his childhood love of Christ. This friend, Isaac Milner, was a physical and intellectual giant.
"By anyone's judgment, Milner was simply his own category, a fantastically outsized figure--a veritable giant--literally and otherwise. We don't know what he weighed or how tall he was, but according to Henry Thornton's daughter Marianne, he was 'the most enormous man it was ever my fate to see in a drawing-room.' He was a behemoth.
As for his mind, it was entirely beyond reckoning: indeed, while at Cambridge, he'd been given the unprecedented distinction of being pronounced 'incomparabilis.' He was what we would today call a super-genius, but the closer one looks, the more one gets the impression that even that superlative doesn't quite capture him, which is both ridiculous and true."
Milner was from Yorkshire, and not a refined gentleman, but a jocular, unpolished man. An ordained Anglican minister who was a scholar of math, chemistry, and physics, Milner's wit was compared to that of Dr. Johnson. He occupied the Cambridge Lucasian Chair of mathematics (currently occupied by Stephen Hawking.) After listing Milner's many distinctions and achievements, the author concludes: "Milner simply cannot really have existed, except perhaps in a tale by Baron von Munchausen."
It was on a journey with Isaac Milner that Wilberforce expressed his opinion that a mutual friend of theirs "carried things too far" (religiously).
The author expresses Wilberforce's opinions of religion:
"It was all good, up to a point. The old doctrines of Christianity and the Bible had served their purposes in their day, but the idea of believing them and preaching them in the late eighteenth century simply seemed willfully anachronistic and silly. Why drag one's feet against the inevitable pull of Progress?"
But, not long after his long talks with Milner, Wilberforce became a Methodist, which of course greatly worried many of his friends. It was this "Great Change," as he called it, that was the beginning of Wilberforce's philanthropic feelings. Really, this seems to me so meaningful to all of us as Christians. Because of Isaac Milner openly talking about Methodism, Wilberforce was born again. Because Wilberforce was born again, he fought for abolition. Because he brought public attention to the suffering of the slaves, people's conscience's were pricked. Because the public conscience was improved, a whole philanthropic movement began, and all of society benefited.
"Wilberforce overturned not just European civilization's view of slavery, but its view of almost everything in the human sphere; and that is why it's nearly impossible to do justice to he enormity of this accomplishment: it was nothing less than a fundamental and important shift in human consciousness."
Wilberforce not only got slavery abolished, but with his popularity and persuasiveness actually did the unthinkable at the time: He made loving your fellow man fashionable. Before Wilberforce, there was no such thing as "noblesse oblige." Everyone simply assumed that the poor and unfortunate were being punished by God. To intervene and try to help them would be to interfere in the Divine plan.
However, after Wilberforce, by the Victorian era, philanthropy had been popular so long that it was actually mocked (for example, by Mark Twain, in one short story I've read.) To think that this great change in what society accepts was initiated by only two people, one of whom was a Yorkshire man of common stock, is all the inspiration any of us should need to try and initiate change in the world we live in today. The climax, when slavery is finally abolished in Britain, brings tears of hope and joy to one's eyes.
All quotes taken from Amazing Grace by Eric Metaxas, HarperSanFrancisco, copyright 2007.
In William Wilberforce, I feel that I've found a kindred soul: one who sought to fight evil in spite of his health, in spite of the hatred of the world directed at him for "forcing his religious beliefs on others," in spite of cultural stigmata against all his beliefs and even who he was. It really inspired me to fight the evil that I see in our world, and gave me ideas on how success could be achieved, and how long it will most likely take to see change.
Eric Metaxas, the author, focused mainly on the man himself and his fight against slavery. Unlike the movie, there is less of a storyline, but the main events of his life are all there: election to parliament, conversion, marriage, children, illness, and so on. The political situation in England is described in much greater detail than in the movie, as is Wilberforce's conversion. Metaxas accomplishes his history with a lot of wit, to his credit. I laughed out loud several times while reading it, and some parts warranted an immediate, "Honey, you have to read this part" by my husband.
From his childhood, Wilberforce always showed remarkable compassion and sensitivity. Though his parents were nominal Christians at best (the norm for English people of the day) Wilberforce had the blessing, at a young age, to become a foster child in the home of some extended family who were Methodists.
To understand Wilberforce's upbringing, we must also understand the connotation of the word "Methodist" to Wilberforce's contemporaries. To explain that attitude, we have to remember the fallout of the Reformation and the Counter-Reformation, and all the bloodshed and burnings that resulted. With some of these events less than 200 years in the past, the prevailing attitude about religion was that it was dangerous. Everyone pretty much believed that we all have to take our religion lightly, and just go to church, and not get too excited about it, because "we all know" what happens when people get too excited about religion. English churches were boring, and didn't attempt to be anything else.
George Whitefield, a Methodist preacher without a pulpit who was cross-eyed and preached in the fields, had unusual religious fervor at this time, and it was contagious. Because of the Methodists' emotional fervor and disregard for conventional restraint, the term "Methodist" quickly came to be almost synonymous with "religious wacko." The term "fundamentalist" is comparable, today, in its connotation.
It was in this house of Methodist relatives that William first became interested in Christianity, and showed every sign of turning from his parents' life of frivolity and carnality to an austere spiritual life. But, his mother, seeing the change in her son, soon put an end to that, by bringing him home to be "cultured" by attending the opera and theater.
From the book, "Wilberforce was one of the brightest, wittiest, best connected, and generally talented men of his day, someone who might well have become prime minister of Great Britain if he had, in the words of one historian, 'preferred the party to mankind.' But his accomplishments far transcend any mere political victory. Wilberforce can be pictured as standing as a kind of hinge in the middle of history: he pulled the world around a corner, and we can't even look back to see where we've come from."
It wasn't until after Wilberforce was elected to parliament and some conversations with a very thoughtful and spiritual friend that he began to return to his childhood love of Christ. This friend, Isaac Milner, was a physical and intellectual giant.
"By anyone's judgment, Milner was simply his own category, a fantastically outsized figure--a veritable giant--literally and otherwise. We don't know what he weighed or how tall he was, but according to Henry Thornton's daughter Marianne, he was 'the most enormous man it was ever my fate to see in a drawing-room.' He was a behemoth.
As for his mind, it was entirely beyond reckoning: indeed, while at Cambridge, he'd been given the unprecedented distinction of being pronounced 'incomparabilis.' He was what we would today call a super-genius, but the closer one looks, the more one gets the impression that even that superlative doesn't quite capture him, which is both ridiculous and true."
Milner was from Yorkshire, and not a refined gentleman, but a jocular, unpolished man. An ordained Anglican minister who was a scholar of math, chemistry, and physics, Milner's wit was compared to that of Dr. Johnson. He occupied the Cambridge Lucasian Chair of mathematics (currently occupied by Stephen Hawking.) After listing Milner's many distinctions and achievements, the author concludes: "Milner simply cannot really have existed, except perhaps in a tale by Baron von Munchausen."
It was on a journey with Isaac Milner that Wilberforce expressed his opinion that a mutual friend of theirs "carried things too far" (religiously).
The author expresses Wilberforce's opinions of religion:
"It was all good, up to a point. The old doctrines of Christianity and the Bible had served their purposes in their day, but the idea of believing them and preaching them in the late eighteenth century simply seemed willfully anachronistic and silly. Why drag one's feet against the inevitable pull of Progress?"
But, not long after his long talks with Milner, Wilberforce became a Methodist, which of course greatly worried many of his friends. It was this "Great Change," as he called it, that was the beginning of Wilberforce's philanthropic feelings. Really, this seems to me so meaningful to all of us as Christians. Because of Isaac Milner openly talking about Methodism, Wilberforce was born again. Because Wilberforce was born again, he fought for abolition. Because he brought public attention to the suffering of the slaves, people's conscience's were pricked. Because the public conscience was improved, a whole philanthropic movement began, and all of society benefited.
"Wilberforce overturned not just European civilization's view of slavery, but its view of almost everything in the human sphere; and that is why it's nearly impossible to do justice to he enormity of this accomplishment: it was nothing less than a fundamental and important shift in human consciousness."
Wilberforce not only got slavery abolished, but with his popularity and persuasiveness actually did the unthinkable at the time: He made loving your fellow man fashionable. Before Wilberforce, there was no such thing as "noblesse oblige." Everyone simply assumed that the poor and unfortunate were being punished by God. To intervene and try to help them would be to interfere in the Divine plan.
However, after Wilberforce, by the Victorian era, philanthropy had been popular so long that it was actually mocked (for example, by Mark Twain, in one short story I've read.) To think that this great change in what society accepts was initiated by only two people, one of whom was a Yorkshire man of common stock, is all the inspiration any of us should need to try and initiate change in the world we live in today. The climax, when slavery is finally abolished in Britain, brings tears of hope and joy to one's eyes.
All quotes taken from Amazing Grace by Eric Metaxas, HarperSanFrancisco, copyright 2007.
