Helpful Score: 11
I had high hopes for this book but all of them were dashed. There is so much that is wrong with this book though the premise is not one of them. On the surface, a story about a 12-year old girl who disappears without a trace only to return four years later is one that is full of promise. Unfortunately, every promise made in this book is broken, thrown to the ground and trampled on. Why make a huge point of the girl lying to the father early on when it means absolutely nothing? Why would the police arrest a man who abducted and abused a girl for four years and let him go within 24 hours? Why would a woman condemn her brother-in-law for lying on one page only to run to his defense three pages later? And why on earth would any father agree to return his sixteen year old daughter to the man who abducted her??? There is not one sympathetic character in this book and not one who can be trusted. What a waste of time. Ugh.
Helpful Score: 8
This book centers around a parents' worst nightmare - the mysterious disappearance of their daughter. Fast forward four years after the disappearance of their twelve year old daughter Caitlin, Tom and Abby Stuart are still mourning the "death" of their daughter. Their once strong marriage is now fractured and while Tom holds out hope that Caitlin is still alive, Abby has given up all hope. When Caitlin resurfaces, Tom is driven to uncover who took his daughter and the events of the last four years. I enjoyed the book a lot and found it a compelling read. A few things disturbed me about the book, such as the portrayal of the young girl's "feelings" towards the man who abducted her. A little too creepy and not necessarily realistic depiction of a father's feelings towards his daughter's abductor and rapist.
Helpful Score: 4
Tom and Abby Stuart seem to be a couple with the perfect life until their wonderful 12-year old daughter, Caitlin, disappears without a trace. The only witness to Caitlins disappearance is the family dog. Abby finds solace at church, Tom endures by tracking every lead and keeping their daughters story out there. Their marriage starts to fall apart as they are both pulled in different directions. Abby needs closure and Tom needs to keep hope alive.
Four years later their world is rocked again when Caitlin is found alive..
Dollycas Thoughts
I think the book cover synopsis gives away too much of the story and loses some of the suspense. That being said it is a gripping story. The psychological part of the story is very compelling as all three main characters deal with serious issues. Losing a child is devastating enough but having them return after time, while fantastic, trying to acclimate together again can be overwhelming.
The entire story is told from Toms point of view and his pain, agony, fear, mistrust, sadness and grief are all poured out on these pages. As his childhood memories are revealed you feel even more of these emotions. At times I thought her was hallucinating visions of his daughter, his mind trying to cope. Maybe because I was taking this journey so closely with Tom I found myself really not liking Abby and her relationship with her pastor really upset me.
This author has a voice I will continue to watch. This is a smart novel with keen insight. There are many layers in this story that add to the story making it different from other stories with a similar premise. Parents will hug their kids tight after reading this all too real nightmare.
Disclosure of Material Connection: I received this book free from New American Library. I was not required to write a positive review. The opinions I have expressed are my own. Receiving a complimentary copy in no way reflected my review of this book. I am disclosing this in accordance with the Federal Trade Commissions 16 CFR, Part 255 : Guides Concerning the Use of Endorsements and Testimonials in Advertising.
Four years later their world is rocked again when Caitlin is found alive..
Dollycas Thoughts
I think the book cover synopsis gives away too much of the story and loses some of the suspense. That being said it is a gripping story. The psychological part of the story is very compelling as all three main characters deal with serious issues. Losing a child is devastating enough but having them return after time, while fantastic, trying to acclimate together again can be overwhelming.
The entire story is told from Toms point of view and his pain, agony, fear, mistrust, sadness and grief are all poured out on these pages. As his childhood memories are revealed you feel even more of these emotions. At times I thought her was hallucinating visions of his daughter, his mind trying to cope. Maybe because I was taking this journey so closely with Tom I found myself really not liking Abby and her relationship with her pastor really upset me.
This author has a voice I will continue to watch. This is a smart novel with keen insight. There are many layers in this story that add to the story making it different from other stories with a similar premise. Parents will hug their kids tight after reading this all too real nightmare.
Disclosure of Material Connection: I received this book free from New American Library. I was not required to write a positive review. The opinions I have expressed are my own. Receiving a complimentary copy in no way reflected my review of this book. I am disclosing this in accordance with the Federal Trade Commissions 16 CFR, Part 255 : Guides Concerning the Use of Endorsements and Testimonials in Advertising.
Helpful Score: 4
This book is from the point of view of a middle aged man. I have never read a story from this prospective and I must say that the point of view in this story was fascinating. When a child goes missing normally you would look to the mother or possibly the child's point of view. It was a quick read and the story flows very easily. I really enjoyed getting out of my comfort zone and reading this book.
Helpful Score: 3
I wasn't going to review this book HOWEVER I can see there is mixed feelings about the storyline
It did keep my interest and I finished it in one day but the last few chapters I thought were ridiculous, there was just too much wrong with what happened when Catlin came home and most of it I thought is unbelievable BUT you have to realize--it is just a story in a book, I would sure hope that it would never happen in a real situation
So I give it 3 stars just because it will keep your interest
It did keep my interest and I finished it in one day but the last few chapters I thought were ridiculous, there was just too much wrong with what happened when Catlin came home and most of it I thought is unbelievable BUT you have to realize--it is just a story in a book, I would sure hope that it would never happen in a real situation
So I give it 3 stars just because it will keep your interest
Helpful Score: 2
This wasn't outstanding, but has merit. The author did a fine job of writing and revealing the story, albeit a creepy story. Parents suffer four years of their missing daughter. When she returns she is obviously different than when she disappeared. What they discover is heartbreaking and disturbing. The subject matter made me squirmish and thus, I guess that is what the author intended. Good for you David Bell.
Helpful Score: 2
I normally read Christian Fiction, but this just looked so interesting, I had to read it. There was a bit of language in here, but in retrospect, it was just part of the character's personality.
There was plenty of suspense to keep you turning the pages. Definitely worth reading!
There was plenty of suspense to keep you turning the pages. Definitely worth reading!
Helpful Score: 1
I thought the first half of this book was excellent - a 12 year-old girl disappears, then four years later clues are uncovered regarding her whereabouts, rekindling the hope that she is in fact still alive. Soon she is found and returned to her parents, whose marriage is barely hanging on by a thread. The author did a great job describing the emotional suspense of the family's reunion: Tom Stuart wants everything to go back to normal, however Abby had forced herself to move on, accepting that her daughter had been murdered. The pieces do not simply fall back into place, and when Caitlin's abductor is found and arrested, things get worse - she refuses to testify against him and actually wants to go back to him. All of those emotions and reactions are kind of horrible, yet believable in some strange way, however after that the story doesn't seem to know which direction to go in, and becomes far-fetched and disappointing. Worth a read, but I was a little disappointed.
Helpful Score: 1
I really enjoyed this book.It was sad,for the parents and the child. A real tear jerker. Life is not always what it seems!
Helpful Score: 1
I was extremely disappointed in this book. I was intrigued by the premise, but I never really felt like the story developed well. There were so many pieces and the author didn't tie them together well. I just got the impression that he was gathering ideas from friends and sticking them into the story whether they really had anything to do with where the book was to go or not. This is not a book I can highly recommend, but someone else may find it just great.
Only book I have read by this author.....I had it on my shelf for quite a while planning to read it....put it off for other "new releases" by my favorite authors & my daughter read it & raved about how good it was. Finally started reading it yesterday & found it hard to put down as I just HAD to know "what happened to Caitlin"??? Just finished the book minutes ago.....really liked it!!! Very interesting storyline.....if you get a chance to read this one grab it!
I really enjoyed this book. It was fast-paced with good, tight writing. I'll look for more books by this author.
Tom and Abby Stuart thought they had everything: a perfect marriage, successful careers, and a sweet, beautiful twelve-year-old daughter named Caitlin. Then one day Caitlin vanished without a trace. For a while they grasped at every false hope and followed every empty lead, hoping that Caitlin would be found safe. But the tragedy ultimately ended up changing their lives, overwhelming them with guilt and dread, and shattering their marriage.
Four years later, Caitlin is found alive - dirty and disheveled yet eerily calm. She won't discuss where she was or what happened. And she is fundamentally changed by the ordeal.
When the police arrest a suspect connected to Caitlin's disappearance, she refuses to testify against him. So the Stuarts are faced with a devastating choice: Let the man who may be responsible for destroying their lives walk away, or take matters into their own hands. And when Tom decides to try to uncover the truth for himself, he finds that nothing that has happened can possibly prepare him for what he is about to discover.
In my opinion, this book was absolutely excellent! The story was extremely intriguing and captured my attention right from the beginning. It was a poignant book for me to read as well - fast-paced and well-written, holding my attention throughout the entire book. I give David Bell's debut novel a definite A+!
Four years later, Caitlin is found alive - dirty and disheveled yet eerily calm. She won't discuss where she was or what happened. And she is fundamentally changed by the ordeal.
When the police arrest a suspect connected to Caitlin's disappearance, she refuses to testify against him. So the Stuarts are faced with a devastating choice: Let the man who may be responsible for destroying their lives walk away, or take matters into their own hands. And when Tom decides to try to uncover the truth for himself, he finds that nothing that has happened can possibly prepare him for what he is about to discover.
In my opinion, this book was absolutely excellent! The story was extremely intriguing and captured my attention right from the beginning. It was a poignant book for me to read as well - fast-paced and well-written, holding my attention throughout the entire book. I give David Bell's debut novel a definite A+!
This book sounded good from the synopsis, but it was really a dud. About halfway thru the book, it started getting boring and the last part of the book was such a letdown. Would not recommend it for reading. I will try his next book The Hiding Place and see if it is any better.
Thought this was going to be so interesting, suspenseful and tense but it was so not that. The storyline began to disturb me about chapter 3.
Not a book to enter into lightly and really does not give a full story pic on the back cover.
Daughter is kidnapped, found but wants to live with her kidnapper not her family.
Not a book to enter into lightly and really does not give a full story pic on the back cover.
Daughter is kidnapped, found but wants to live with her kidnapper not her family.
Stupid ridiculous story not worth your time. Nothing to save this being a total dud.
This book was fast paced, but the plot was not as great as promised in reviews. Basically I did not enjoy reading it.
I am in agreement with most of the other reviewers for this book. Cemetery Girl had me right from the start. It is a really gripping story. Unfortunately, it goes horribly wrong at the end. There is really no resolution to the story. It just sort of ends. And getting to the end was when I thought everything would be explained. That a-ha! you always look for in a mystery. It just wasn't there.
