Elizabeth R. (esjro) -
Helpful Score: 2
The Collaborator of Bethlehem is an foreign take on the classic amateur detective story, but this one is definitely not a cozy! Omar Yussef is a middle-aged school teacher living in Bethlehem. When one of his favorite former Christian students is accused of collaborating with the Israeli army in the assasination of a local violent Palestinian activist, Yussef abandons his quiet intellectual life to prove his student's innocence. His investigation forces him to confront those with whom he shares ideals, but who have turned to the extremism and violence that he cautions his students against.
The murder plot itself is not particularly novel, but the insight Rees' provides into life in the Palestinian camps is. Though not overly political, this book is mildly anti-Israeli. However, Rees is very balanced in his treatment of the Palestinians - he is sympathetic to their cause, but critical of some of their means.
This is the first in a series of murders featuring the school teacher/detective. I have added the second to my wishlist. I highly recommend this book to mystery lovers who are looking for something different.
The murder plot itself is not particularly novel, but the insight Rees' provides into life in the Palestinian camps is. Though not overly political, this book is mildly anti-Israeli. However, Rees is very balanced in his treatment of the Palestinians - he is sympathetic to their cause, but critical of some of their means.
This is the first in a series of murders featuring the school teacher/detective. I have added the second to my wishlist. I highly recommend this book to mystery lovers who are looking for something different.
Cheryl R. (Spuddie) -
#1 Omar Yussef mystery set in Bethlehem, Israel. Omar Yussef is a fifty-six-year-old history teacher, an alcoholic who's been dry for ten years. Obviously not a devout Muslim, he does the best he can in an ever-changing, violent world to teach his students right from wrong and respect for all. When one of his former students, George Saba, is accused of being a collaborator with the Israelites and murdering one of the local heros, Omar takes a leave of absence from his school and sets out to investigate so he can prove his friend's innocence.
Of course, he's been living too long with his head in an idealistic cloud, and in reality, those in power need a scapegoat and since they hold all the cards, they thwart Omar Yussef's efforts at every turn. After awhile, he isn't even sure that people he's considered close friends and confidantes (including the head of the police in Bethlehem) for many years aren't pulling strings against him. Does he take the easy way out and go with the flow to keep his family safe, or does he soldier on in the name of what he believes is right? Probably not a dilemma many of us can identify with on a very real and visceral level.
Despite being in a setting that is brand new to me, with lots of interesting cultural details, one thing the book shows is that humans are human wherever you go--and motives for murder like power and greed cross national, religious and cultural borders. Very interesting first entry in series. It's difficult to read about an area of the world that has existed as a war-torn scrap of land for so very long, but I am always glad to learn about new areas and cultures.
I did figure the mystery out ahead of time, but it was just a good guess or my gut feeling--I felt like I was on shaky ground being so unfamiliar with the culture and missed a lot of clues, I think, and sometimes had to stop to rearrange my thoughts. I liked Omar despite his sometimes petty vanity and stubbornness and I look forward to getting to know him better.
Of course, he's been living too long with his head in an idealistic cloud, and in reality, those in power need a scapegoat and since they hold all the cards, they thwart Omar Yussef's efforts at every turn. After awhile, he isn't even sure that people he's considered close friends and confidantes (including the head of the police in Bethlehem) for many years aren't pulling strings against him. Does he take the easy way out and go with the flow to keep his family safe, or does he soldier on in the name of what he believes is right? Probably not a dilemma many of us can identify with on a very real and visceral level.
Despite being in a setting that is brand new to me, with lots of interesting cultural details, one thing the book shows is that humans are human wherever you go--and motives for murder like power and greed cross national, religious and cultural borders. Very interesting first entry in series. It's difficult to read about an area of the world that has existed as a war-torn scrap of land for so very long, but I am always glad to learn about new areas and cultures.
I did figure the mystery out ahead of time, but it was just a good guess or my gut feeling--I felt like I was on shaky ground being so unfamiliar with the culture and missed a lot of clues, I think, and sometimes had to stop to rearrange my thoughts. I liked Omar despite his sometimes petty vanity and stubbornness and I look forward to getting to know him better.
Melody B. (5ducksfans) reviewed The Collaborator of Bethlehem (Omar Yussef, Bk 1) (aka The Bethlehem Murders) on + 92 more book reviews
I can definitely see why Bookmarks Magazine called this one of the great mystery series in its special article about overseas mysteries.
The plot/mystery itself is really good, but the backdrop the novel is set against (primarily the West Bank and its politics) adds another interesting and educational level to this book that most mysteries don't have.
I highly recommend this book and I'm thrilled to have found a new series to start!
The plot/mystery itself is really good, but the backdrop the novel is set against (primarily the West Bank and its politics) adds another interesting and educational level to this book that most mysteries don't have.
I highly recommend this book and I'm thrilled to have found a new series to start!
LeeAnne (Beanbean) reviewed The Collaborator of Bethlehem (Omar Yussef, Bk 1) (aka The Bethlehem Murders) on + 56 more book reviews
Fascinating look at a culture that as Americans, we really don't understand. The mystery is tight and well-written with a strong and likable protagonist. I'll be looking to read more Omar Yussef mysteries.
Cathy C. (cathyskye) -
Rees has created a story with a superb sense of time and place, and he does so by showing the humanity of all sides. The monsters aren't all Palestinian. Or Israeli. The mistakes being made aren't all being made by Palestinians or Israelis. And there are good people on every side. This is a story to experience. A story for the mind and for the emotions.
One of the good people is Omar Yussef, who feels that he may be coming to the end of his usefulness. He can't seem to stop being angry at the children in his class who do nothing but spout political clichés, but when he tries to destroy their hate and their blindness, all he seems to do is make himself angrier and the children distrustful of him.
The plight of George Saba is a godsend for this man. Yussef has a deep-seated need to fight injustice. For years he's been buffeted by the winds of political and religious unrest, but he is still willing to stand up for what he believes in. The power of Rees's writing is that while the reader is cheering Yussef for his bravery, he is also afraid because of what may happen to this one solitary man.
Yussef isn't Mr. Perfect. He may endear himself to us by telling us of the power of his wife's cooking or of what he believes to be the most important thing about teaching. He may enlighten us about the proliferation of murals depicting the Alps inside Bethlehem's homes, but the years have soured him a bit. He's not always right about the people he comes in contact with every day. Readers have to keep an eye on Yussef as they follow his investigation.
Omar Yussef is told early on in The Collaborator of Bethlehem that "In Palestine, there's no such thing as a good detective." Yussef still has much to learn, but I think it's safe to say that Palestine now has that badly needed investigator.
One of the good people is Omar Yussef, who feels that he may be coming to the end of his usefulness. He can't seem to stop being angry at the children in his class who do nothing but spout political clichés, but when he tries to destroy their hate and their blindness, all he seems to do is make himself angrier and the children distrustful of him.
The plight of George Saba is a godsend for this man. Yussef has a deep-seated need to fight injustice. For years he's been buffeted by the winds of political and religious unrest, but he is still willing to stand up for what he believes in. The power of Rees's writing is that while the reader is cheering Yussef for his bravery, he is also afraid because of what may happen to this one solitary man.
Yussef isn't Mr. Perfect. He may endear himself to us by telling us of the power of his wife's cooking or of what he believes to be the most important thing about teaching. He may enlighten us about the proliferation of murals depicting the Alps inside Bethlehem's homes, but the years have soured him a bit. He's not always right about the people he comes in contact with every day. Readers have to keep an eye on Yussef as they follow his investigation.
Omar Yussef is told early on in The Collaborator of Bethlehem that "In Palestine, there's no such thing as a good detective." Yussef still has much to learn, but I think it's safe to say that Palestine now has that badly needed investigator.
