Skip to main content
PBS logo
 
 

Book Reviews of The Dark Horse (Walt Longmire, Bk 5)

The Dark Horse (Walt Longmire, Bk 5)
The Dark Horse - Walt Longmire, Bk 5
Author: Craig Johnson
ISBN-13: 9780670020874
ISBN-10: 0670020877
Publication Date: 5/28/2009
Pages: 320
Rating:
  • Currently 4.2/5 Stars.
 23

4.2 stars, based on 23 ratings
Publisher: Viking Adult
Book Type: Hardcover
Reviews: Amazon | Write a Review

10 Book Reviews submitted by our Members...sorted by voted most helpful

cathyskye avatar reviewed The Dark Horse (Walt Longmire, Bk 5) on + 2307 more book reviews
Helpful Score: 2
When I began blogging last June, one of the very first authors I raved about was Craig Johnson. Get ready to listen to more raves because my opinion of him is unchanged.

In this fifth book of the series, we see the Sheriff of Absaroka County, Wyoming, working undercover as an insurance agent in the tiny, ill-tempered town of Absalom. Absalom resident Wade Barstad, well-known womanizer and jerk-about-town, set fire to his barn. The fire roasted alive his wife's horses, which didn't set too well with Mary. Mary Barstad waited till Wade went to bed. She then proceeded to put six bullets in his head and set fire to the house. When the fire department showed up, Mary confessed to killing her husband. But the sheriff in that county smells a rat, and he soon has Walt Longmire sniffing the very same eau de rongeur. Seeing as how most Absalom residents would just as soon shoot strangers as look at 'em, will Walt have enough time to figure out what really happened?

Although Johnson writes of his corner of Wyoming as if it's a character in and of itself, it's really the two-legged ones for whom you want to read this series. Each a rugged individualist, learning everyone's outlooks on life as well as their relationships with the other characters is the meat and potatoes of these books. The mystery is the huge wedge of lemon meringue pie that puts a satisfied PAID to the entire meal.

It's difficult to write a novel about the West and not have the landscape have its say. Just ask Hillerman or Bowen or Box...or Craig Johnson:

"I thought about how we tilled and cultivated the land, planted trees on it, fenced it, built houses on it, and did everything we could to hold off the eternity of distance-- anything to give the landscape some sort of human scale. No matter what we did to try and form the West, however, the West inevitably formed us instead."



Walt Longmire was raised by his mother to respect and help the young, the old and the infirm. He's the type of person who can stare at the wall around a pay phone and think

"People had written and scratched things so deeply that re-paintings had only heightened the sentiment. I wondered if Custer really wore Arrow shirts, if DD still loved NT, if the eleven kids that got left at the parking lot were still beating the Broncos twenty-four to three, or if 758-4331 was still a good time. I thought about the love, heartbreaks, and desperate passions that had been played out through the phone in my hand...."


No matter how he may try to dissemble, when the chips are down you want Walt Longmire guarding your back. The man who can wonder about DD and NT truly gives a damn.

The book is told in two alternating time frames: the present while Walt is undercover, and the two weeks leading to his arrival in Absalom. Although this had me chafing at the bit a few times, it did serve two purposes: reminding us why Walt thought Mary Barstad was important enough to risk his life for, and giving us doses of Walt's co-workers and friends who couldn't follow him into this investigation. This series isn't the Walt Longmire Show; the secondary characters are just as well-drawn and easy to get attached to as he is.

Although I still doubt the wisdom of having a character like Walt go undercover practically on his own home turf, I loved this book. In a nostalgic post a few days ago, I mentioned being horse crazy, which was a bit prophetic. The Dark Horse was drawing to a close. Walt had to save someone's life and the only transportation available to take him down off a high mesa and toward help was a magnificent black horse. I swear, if someone had interrupted me at that moment, I wouldn't have bothered with a gun or a baseball bat or a scream of rage. I would've let fly with one of my Spontaneous Combustion Looks-- guaranteed to flash fry the recipient down to his Tony Lamas in one-tenth of a second.

Craig Johnson turned back my clock. While my adult brain was being very well taken care of, I was also a child, sitting here with my eyes glued to the page, reading about a hero and a horse and a race against time. Not many writers are skilled enough to satisfy on so many levels. Johnson is one of the few.
Spuddie avatar reviewed The Dark Horse (Walt Longmire, Bk 5) on + 412 more book reviews
#5 Walt Longmire mystery set in Wyoming. The elections are coming up and Sheriff Longmire is avoiding thinking about it, and things are a bit slow in Absaroka County. Walt's daughter Cady has returned to her home in Philadelphia and he's at loose ends. The Sheriff of a neighboring county sends him a puzzle to chew on and a prisoner to house since their jail is overflowing and Walt eagerly jumps into it.

Mary Barsad has confessed to shooting her husband Wade six times in the head after he set their barn afire--with her beloved horses inside. Wade was universally disliked, and were it not for Mary's confession, the suspect list would be a mile long--and would include some ghosts from his past, as he was in the witness protection program. But after talking with Mary, Walt doesn't believe she's guilty--and he goes undercover in Jackson County, posing as an insurance investigator--although his cover doesn't last very long. (I kind of wondered about that, anyway. Walt was born and raised very near where all this action took place and he recognized a few of the characters--so why would they NOT recognize him?)

As usual, this was a well-told story in a wonderful voice, and the book was nearly impossible to put down. I love Walt, I love his cast of secondary characters, including the great state of Wyoming, which Johnson obviously loves. With a perfect balance of slow, rambling detail and fast-paced action, and a plot twist I didn't see coming at all, this will likely make my top ten of the year list.

The only thing missing for me was the voice of George Guidall who narrates the audio versions--I listened to three of the previous four books and could hear his version of Walt's voice faintly at the back of my mind as I read along.
perryfran avatar reviewed The Dark Horse (Walt Longmire, Bk 5) on + 1223 more book reviews
I've been enjoying the Longmire series on A&E so decided to see how the novels compare. I would say the books are even better than the TV show. "Dark Horse" is the 5th novel in the series and actually one of the Longmire TV shows was based on this novel about a barn that catches fire and destroys several prized horses. Well, the book really fleshes out the Longmire character along with his supporting cast - Victoria (Vic), his deputy; and Henry Standing Bear, his American Indian consort. Overall, I really enjoyed this one and will be looking out for the rest of the series.
MKSbooklady avatar reviewed The Dark Horse (Walt Longmire, Bk 5) on + 989 more book reviews
Another solid book from Craig Johnson. It might take a few chapters to get used to the different time frames used in this book. But Sheriff Longmire is as steady as ever, whether he's riding a horse or driving a pick up.
reviewed The Dark Horse (Walt Longmire, Bk 5) on + 3 more book reviews
Every time I read a book by Craig Johnson, I think all over again that he is the best mystery writer, if not the best of any kind of writer, that I can think of. Yet each book is different, comes from a different place (all in the same setting), and goes in a different direction. He creates a tremendous sense of place, he fleshes out his characters beautifully, and his plots are always surprising. This book is no exception as it pits Walt against some strong evil which he overcomes with the help of his best friend and a few new good guys.
ladycholla avatar reviewed The Dark Horse (Walt Longmire, Bk 5) on + 2081 more book reviews
My husband enjoyed this very much and got laughs in several places.
junie avatar reviewed The Dark Horse (Walt Longmire, Bk 5) on + 630 more book reviews
Well this is the second Walt Longmire book I couldn't get through. I really tried because I like the TV series, and I love C.J.Box's Joe Pickett and both take place in Wyoming and thought they may be similar . How wrong I was!
cyndij avatar reviewed The Dark Horse (Walt Longmire, Bk 5) on + 1032 more book reviews
#5 in the Longmire series and another excellent read. A woman prisoner is transferred into the Absaroka County jail. She's confessed to killing her husband, who burned her horses alive in their barn. But Longmire's intuition tells him something isn't quite right, the guy who transferred the woman also says something's not quite right, and so Longmire takes it on himself to go undercover and find out more. The tiny town where it all happened has more than its share of secrets, and things not so secret. Told with a lot of back and forth between past and present, but obvious when it shifts. It's mostly Longmire on his own in this one although Henry Standing Bear shows up to help out once again. There's humor as always - Longmire's undercover act lasts about 5 minutes, and Henry's excuse for appearing is also pretty amusing. I really like how Johnson has made Longmire into such a thoughtful character; he is very observant and doesn't leap to conclusions. The sense of place is, as always, very evocative. The ending - on the mesa in the middle of the night, a dark horse appearing - was particularly suspenseful.
reviewed The Dark Horse (Walt Longmire, Bk 5) on
one of his better books
reviewed The Dark Horse (Walt Longmire, Bk 5) on + 43 more book reviews
Like all Longmire books it is a great read that lets you escape into Walts world and