Helpful Score: 6
I have a really difficult time saying that I simply liked this book, because it was actually quite difficult to read. Hoffman is describing abuses and atrocities, and though she does it tastefull and not gratuitously, there were moments that were very heavy for me (especially as a mother). In fact, I read the book as part of a book group; several members mentioned that they were not able to "stomach" the book. That said, it was emotionally poignant, historically accurate and informative, and beautifully and descriptively written. I recommend it highly, with the warning that it's a violent book...sort of.
Helpful Score: 5
One of the best books I have read in a while! The story of these remarkable characters just made me want to keep on reading. I actually missed them when the book was finished!
Helpful Score: 5
I just loved this book. It's the story of Masada told through the lives of four women.Each is a totally different personality and has a different plac e in the story. The characters are so well developed that the reader really feels some emotion about each one. What brought each woman to the mountain? How did she and others survive for the time they were there? Although I knew a lot of the history, There was still much to learn about the times and thr skills they developed to live from day to day.
The writing is beautiful. It helps one to enter this terrifying time. I strongly recommend it.
The writing is beautiful. It helps one to enter this terrifying time. I strongly recommend it.
Helpful Score: 4
This book is a beautifully written, very descriptive and dramatic account of the times, people and situation but it is a very heavy read and sometimes tedious.
Helpful Score: 2
I read this book in two days having to stop to go to work. Masada has always fascinated me and I totally enjoyed it from the view of women. Alice Hoffman's best.
