Susan F. (scoutmomskf) -
Good book. James and Ivy had met briefly five years earlier at the first ball she attended. James was a soldier, headed off to war the next day. They shared a kiss that neither has ever forgotten. Life intervened and they hadn't seen each other since.
Now, Ivy and her sisters live in seclusion at Fenwick Manor. The night of the ball her father was accused of cheating at cards and was killed in a duel. Since then, Ivy and her sisters have been scrimping and saving to pay off his debts. They have finally succeeded in that, but if they are going to keep their home they need some income. Ivy decides that she will find a position as a governess.
James recently returned from the war with a career ending injury. After his father's death it's up to him to fulfill his ducal duties. He's not quite ready to marry and have kids, so he decides to invite a potential mistress to his home and live it up for a few weeks first. On his way to his estate, he passes Fenwick and decides he wants to buy it, whether the owner wants to sell or not. His encounter in the garden is pretty amusing. When he arrives at his home, he discovers his niece and nephew in residence. His brother is still at war and the children's mother has run off with her lover. He doesn't want to change his plans with his mistress, so he decides to hire a governess. His first interview is with Ivy who he recognizes and decides to hire.
The attraction is still there, but they initially plan to ignore it, even though a shared kiss is inflammatory. Ivy needs the money and James still wants his time to play. But resistance is futile and James soon decides that Ivy would be the perfect wife for him. He just needs to woo her to his way of thinking. The chemistry between them is hot, and they discover that they can't keep their hands off each other. Another man shows up, wanting to court Ivy, which gives James more motivation to claim Ivy as quickly as he can.
The other man, Oliver, actually has more on his mind than winning Ivy. She is just the means to an end. He has heard that there is a treasure hidden at Fenwick and he wants it. Though he is pursuing Ivy, he also wonders if he'd do better to go after one of the other sisters instead. Though his reasons for being there aren't the best, he does have some redeeming qualities. There's also a surprise connection to the prospective mistress. In the end, Oliver ends up on the right side of the issues. I have a feeling he'll be playing a larger role in a future book.
I liked seeing the relationship develop between Ivy and James, though I sometimes felt that he was relying too much on the physical to win her. I enjoyed his protectiveness as the strange happenings at Fenwick Manor became more dangerous. I also liked the way Ivy took care of James when his war injury flared up. The epilogue was great and shows good promise for their future.
The mystery of the Fenwick treasure ran throughout the book. Oliver certainly created some real problems for them with his pursuit of it. I didn't feel like there was a real resolution with it, so I expect that it will show up again in later books.
Now, Ivy and her sisters live in seclusion at Fenwick Manor. The night of the ball her father was accused of cheating at cards and was killed in a duel. Since then, Ivy and her sisters have been scrimping and saving to pay off his debts. They have finally succeeded in that, but if they are going to keep their home they need some income. Ivy decides that she will find a position as a governess.
James recently returned from the war with a career ending injury. After his father's death it's up to him to fulfill his ducal duties. He's not quite ready to marry and have kids, so he decides to invite a potential mistress to his home and live it up for a few weeks first. On his way to his estate, he passes Fenwick and decides he wants to buy it, whether the owner wants to sell or not. His encounter in the garden is pretty amusing. When he arrives at his home, he discovers his niece and nephew in residence. His brother is still at war and the children's mother has run off with her lover. He doesn't want to change his plans with his mistress, so he decides to hire a governess. His first interview is with Ivy who he recognizes and decides to hire.
The attraction is still there, but they initially plan to ignore it, even though a shared kiss is inflammatory. Ivy needs the money and James still wants his time to play. But resistance is futile and James soon decides that Ivy would be the perfect wife for him. He just needs to woo her to his way of thinking. The chemistry between them is hot, and they discover that they can't keep their hands off each other. Another man shows up, wanting to court Ivy, which gives James more motivation to claim Ivy as quickly as he can.
The other man, Oliver, actually has more on his mind than winning Ivy. She is just the means to an end. He has heard that there is a treasure hidden at Fenwick and he wants it. Though he is pursuing Ivy, he also wonders if he'd do better to go after one of the other sisters instead. Though his reasons for being there aren't the best, he does have some redeeming qualities. There's also a surprise connection to the prospective mistress. In the end, Oliver ends up on the right side of the issues. I have a feeling he'll be playing a larger role in a future book.
I liked seeing the relationship develop between Ivy and James, though I sometimes felt that he was relying too much on the physical to win her. I enjoyed his protectiveness as the strange happenings at Fenwick Manor became more dangerous. I also liked the way Ivy took care of James when his war injury flared up. The epilogue was great and shows good promise for their future.
The mystery of the Fenwick treasure ran throughout the book. Oliver certainly created some real problems for them with his pursuit of it. I didn't feel like there was a real resolution with it, so I expect that it will show up again in later books.
Regina (virgosun) reviewed Forbidden to Love the Duke (Fenwick Sisters Affairs, Bk 1) on + 887 more book reviews
Jillian Hunter is a new author for me, which is rather weird since she has been on the scene for almost as long as I have been reading romance novels. But unless something sounds way out terrific, trying out someone new is risky. I get that. Still, I couldn't resist the delicious possibilities of a forbidden encounter at a masquerade. So, yeah, I was game.
Now, I'm in the story. Absolutely in the moment. I'm with James and Ivy during the ball, the kiss, and the unfortunate events that separates them. No worries. I know eventually they will hook up again, and their close encounter before the actual meet-up was memorable fun. I ate it up. What I didn't see coming was being yanked out of my temporary fantasy. What happened?
Few things about historical romances irritate me more than its characters who act out of character for the period. That's exactly what happened here. Unfortunately, when it did, I couldn't get back to that happy place where I was before. I felt like an observer, constantly distracted by the modern vibe and behavior, kind of the way you can perceive actors acting instead of living their roles. This alone made it an average read for me. In fairness, however, if my peeve isn't yours, the entertaining antics and witty dialogue will certainly keep you engaged in this light-hearted tale, but if you are looking for a more true-to-the-period historical, perhaps this shouldn't be your first choice. 3 stars.
Now, I'm in the story. Absolutely in the moment. I'm with James and Ivy during the ball, the kiss, and the unfortunate events that separates them. No worries. I know eventually they will hook up again, and their close encounter before the actual meet-up was memorable fun. I ate it up. What I didn't see coming was being yanked out of my temporary fantasy. What happened?
Few things about historical romances irritate me more than its characters who act out of character for the period. That's exactly what happened here. Unfortunately, when it did, I couldn't get back to that happy place where I was before. I felt like an observer, constantly distracted by the modern vibe and behavior, kind of the way you can perceive actors acting instead of living their roles. This alone made it an average read for me. In fairness, however, if my peeve isn't yours, the entertaining antics and witty dialogue will certainly keep you engaged in this light-hearted tale, but if you are looking for a more true-to-the-period historical, perhaps this shouldn't be your first choice. 3 stars.
