Cynthia L. (Honeygirl62) -
The book was first written in 1930 and then revised in 1968, so we have come a long way in genealogy since then. However, the basics are the same. I especially liked the chapter explaining dates and the changes in the calendar. The chapter on case histories was very good for examples of problems that needed to be logically worked through.
Jacobus is often regarded as the father of modern, "scientific" genealogy and this short but sweet volume (the first edition of which was published in 1930) is still one of the very best explanations of research principles and guides to types of resource materials published in English. His contemporaries, like Milton Rubincam, regarded it as THE classic, largely because the author was an undisputed master of every aspect of his subject. His many published articles and books were and still are models of critical research and analysis, and The American Genealogist, which he founded in 1922 (as The New Haven Genealogical Magazine) is still one of the best periodicals in the field. The chapters in this volume range far afield, from a discussion of the nature of family pride to the sometimes touchy relationship between genealogy and academic history, from early nomenclature in colonial New England to the impulse to prove royal ancestry. He considers genealogy as a profession (conditions in which, he says, are "unsatisfactory") and how (and whether) to become a professional. Other chapters focus on "The Client" and commercial firms generally (quoting Benjamin Franklin that "Half the Truth is often a great Lie"), and on the practical aspects of putting together a publishable family history, as well as such utilitarian subjects as dating systems and analysis of original sources. This is one of those books that every serious genealogist should reread every few years, just to stay centered.
