Helpful Score: 4
This book has been my number one favorite book for a year now. It is filled with sooooooo many twists, so many different emotions, so many wonderful perfectly detailed characters! Surprising fact after surprising secret, you will regret finnishing this wonderful tale!
Helpful Score: 3
AWESOME! The people of the Seven Kingdoms are magical (well some of them). They call the magic "Graces". So Katsa has the Grace of killing and she is the King of Randa's assassin. On the side, she is involved with the Council who rescues people in danger from the ever-fighting king's. She meets Prince Po at one such rescue. He has the Grace of fighting. Of course, they spar constantly both verbally and physically.
At one point, they leave Randa and travel on a quest to learn why Po's grandfather has been kidnapped. Their journey takes them throughout the entire realm of the Seven Kingdoms which tends to be tedious at times but really builds the relationship between Katsa and Po. It is reminiscent of Sharon Shinn's Mystic and Rider.
The books starts out slow and rather confusing - too many people, too much conflict and the whole Grace this. About halfway through it really grabbed me and totally drew me in. The world building is spectactular and the characters are wonderful. I can't wait til next month to read Fire.
At one point, they leave Randa and travel on a quest to learn why Po's grandfather has been kidnapped. Their journey takes them throughout the entire realm of the Seven Kingdoms which tends to be tedious at times but really builds the relationship between Katsa and Po. It is reminiscent of Sharon Shinn's Mystic and Rider.
The books starts out slow and rather confusing - too many people, too much conflict and the whole Grace this. About halfway through it really grabbed me and totally drew me in. The world building is spectactular and the characters are wonderful. I can't wait til next month to read Fire.
Helpful Score: 2
Finally a YA book with a strong, independent female whose desire isn't to be rescued by some prince or married off with children. There are so many books that already have the whole prince rescues princess, or girl wants boy for marriage/kids. It's been overdone!
So, it is so very refreshing to find a novel where the heroine can fight her own battles, is fiercely independent, has future goals/plans, and, at the same time, isn't so aloof/cold that she can't have relationships, friendships, ask for help when needed, etc.
On top of that, the plot is engaging. I read this in one day. Just fantastic. If I could give it more than 5 stars, I would.
So, it is so very refreshing to find a novel where the heroine can fight her own battles, is fiercely independent, has future goals/plans, and, at the same time, isn't so aloof/cold that she can't have relationships, friendships, ask for help when needed, etc.
On top of that, the plot is engaging. I read this in one day. Just fantastic. If I could give it more than 5 stars, I would.
Helpful Score: 1
I really enjoyed this book. The only issue I had with it was that (spoiler alert) the two main characters decide to become lovers. It is especially troublesome to me because the girl decides she never wants to marry - essentially because of societal pressures/norms on her as a wife. I felt the characters were strong enough that they could have overcome these expectations and it would have made more sense to me. This also kept me from putting it in my school library, as I had intended. It does state high school age on the back, however. I plan to read more books in this series. Cashore is an excellent writer whose characters are compelling! I especially liked the way the main character realizes her grace isn't killing as everyone had presumed, but survival, hence, life!
Stephanie S. (skywriter319) -
Helpful Score: 1
In Katsa's world, those who possess a Grace, an unusually powerful skill, recognized by their different-colored eyes, are often shunned and avoided by the ordinary people. Katsa has it worse than most Graced, for her Grace is the Grace of killing, a Grace that her uncle, King Randa, uses to keep his subjects in line.
But Katsa is sick of always obeying her uncle's orders, being forced to perform these tasks she hates and having to hide her good side. Still, she sees no way out of her miserable, savage life...until she meets Po, a prince from a faraway island kingdom, whose secret business coincides with hers. Po is Graced with the art of combat, and they are well matched in fighting.
A friendship develops between Katsa and Po, and they are thrown together even more as they set off to defend their world from the clutches of a powerful and dangerous king. Katsa must contend with her wild nature if she is to get to know Po, if she is to learn about the truth about their Graces and characters. Together, they may just be able to save their world and make it a better place.
The characterizations of Katsa and Po in Graceling are incredible; it's impossible to not like them and feel for them as they struggle with their internal conflicts and emotions for one another. On the other hand, I felt like much of the plot-conflict in this novel was thrown in almost helter-skelter; conflicts were suddenly introduced and resolved in a matter of pages. I would have liked more back-story, so that I could've better understand Katsa and Po's world. That being said, Graceling is still an incredible debut fantasy novel, sure to appeal to all fantasy lovers who also like a good romance.
But Katsa is sick of always obeying her uncle's orders, being forced to perform these tasks she hates and having to hide her good side. Still, she sees no way out of her miserable, savage life...until she meets Po, a prince from a faraway island kingdom, whose secret business coincides with hers. Po is Graced with the art of combat, and they are well matched in fighting.
A friendship develops between Katsa and Po, and they are thrown together even more as they set off to defend their world from the clutches of a powerful and dangerous king. Katsa must contend with her wild nature if she is to get to know Po, if she is to learn about the truth about their Graces and characters. Together, they may just be able to save their world and make it a better place.
The characterizations of Katsa and Po in Graceling are incredible; it's impossible to not like them and feel for them as they struggle with their internal conflicts and emotions for one another. On the other hand, I felt like much of the plot-conflict in this novel was thrown in almost helter-skelter; conflicts were suddenly introduced and resolved in a matter of pages. I would have liked more back-story, so that I could've better understand Katsa and Po's world. That being said, Graceling is still an incredible debut fantasy novel, sure to appeal to all fantasy lovers who also like a good romance.
Helpful Score: 1
Reviewed by Bibliophile's Bestiary Blog at bibliophile-bestiary.blogspot.com/
Wow! This book was incredible. The world that Kristin Cashore has created is amazing. People are born with a "grace" that shows up when they are children. The grace is known because one of the eyes will change a different color, we know it as heterochromia. The graces that people are gifted with can range from knowing what the weather will be to what Katsa has, a grace of killing easily. While Katsa is very strong, she is oppressed by her uncle, King Randa of the Middluns. While he isn't an 'evil' man, he doesn't always do good things. She longs to have a life away from all the blood shed she is forced to do at the Kings bidding. She starts the Council, an organization that helps people instead of hurting them. When Katsa meets Prince Po, she has feelings for him she doesn't want to feel. They go in search of his grandfather, a Prince of Lienid. They find out many truths about the kingdoms, each other and themselves along the journey. A really excellent read! 5 out of 5 stars!
Wow! This book was incredible. The world that Kristin Cashore has created is amazing. People are born with a "grace" that shows up when they are children. The grace is known because one of the eyes will change a different color, we know it as heterochromia. The graces that people are gifted with can range from knowing what the weather will be to what Katsa has, a grace of killing easily. While Katsa is very strong, she is oppressed by her uncle, King Randa of the Middluns. While he isn't an 'evil' man, he doesn't always do good things. She longs to have a life away from all the blood shed she is forced to do at the Kings bidding. She starts the Council, an organization that helps people instead of hurting them. When Katsa meets Prince Po, she has feelings for him she doesn't want to feel. They go in search of his grandfather, a Prince of Lienid. They find out many truths about the kingdoms, each other and themselves along the journey. A really excellent read! 5 out of 5 stars!
Helpful Score: 1
A wonderful read. Love the characters and relationships. I think that this book just became my all time favorite book. Can't wait to read more.
Reviewed by Allison Fraclose for TeensReadToo.com
In most of the seven kingdoms, people born with a Grace--an extreme skill that they can perform above all others--are usually feared.
However, King Randa of the Middluns kingdom has exploited Katsa's ability to kill ever since her Grace surfaced at the tender age of eight. Katsa had even begun to think that maybe, in reality, she really was nothing but an attack dog, until one day she decided to follow her own will and let an innocent man live. Since then, she and her cousin, Prince Raffin, have put together a secret council to rescue people suffering from similar injustices.
During a rescue mission to free the father of the Lienid king from a dungeon in Sunder, Katsa squares off with a Graced Lienid man who is almost her equal in fighting. When he shows up in Middluns, Katsa is dismayed to learn that he is one of the Lienid princes, nicknamed "Po," in search of his missing grandfather.
Although Katsa is at first wary of his intentions, she soon finds a kindred spirit in Po, and the two grow close as they set off on a journey to solve the mystery surrounding the kidnapping of Po's grandfather. In Monsea, a kingdom isolated by mountains, Po's aunt and young cousin may be in grave danger...
Akin to the tales of Tamora Pierce, this story features strong female characters and an exciting medieval world full of magic and action. Definitely not one to miss!
In most of the seven kingdoms, people born with a Grace--an extreme skill that they can perform above all others--are usually feared.
However, King Randa of the Middluns kingdom has exploited Katsa's ability to kill ever since her Grace surfaced at the tender age of eight. Katsa had even begun to think that maybe, in reality, she really was nothing but an attack dog, until one day she decided to follow her own will and let an innocent man live. Since then, she and her cousin, Prince Raffin, have put together a secret council to rescue people suffering from similar injustices.
During a rescue mission to free the father of the Lienid king from a dungeon in Sunder, Katsa squares off with a Graced Lienid man who is almost her equal in fighting. When he shows up in Middluns, Katsa is dismayed to learn that he is one of the Lienid princes, nicknamed "Po," in search of his missing grandfather.
Although Katsa is at first wary of his intentions, she soon finds a kindred spirit in Po, and the two grow close as they set off on a journey to solve the mystery surrounding the kidnapping of Po's grandfather. In Monsea, a kingdom isolated by mountains, Po's aunt and young cousin may be in grave danger...
Akin to the tales of Tamora Pierce, this story features strong female characters and an exciting medieval world full of magic and action. Definitely not one to miss!
I loved this book. First, it's that great classic combination of intrigue, adventure, and a young person growing up and learning how to be independent. What takes it beyond readability are the engaging writing, sympathetic characters, and some unexpected avoidance of cliches I've come to expect.
Katsa is the king's enforcer/executioner. She hates the job and herself a bit for doing it, but at the beginning doesn't see how to break free of his control. So in her spare time, she's formed a secret council that does good deeds under cover of darkness in an attempt to undo some of the harm she and the king have done. A mission introduces her to Prince Po and a boatload of conspiracy and intrigue, which naturally leads to them going on a mission to find out the truth and possibly rescue a few people and topple a monarchy.
The Seven Kingdoms are like many Fantasylands with their vaguely medieval setups, but Cashore doesn't always follow the script, fortunately. Like many fantasy heroines, Katsa doesn't like wearing dresses - but only because they get in the way of her work, not because she thinks dresses are inherently evil creations. She quite likes her nurse, who is very much pro-dress. She doesn't want to get married - not because she hates men, but because the legal aspects of marriage in her society are unfair, and she thinks that would wreck even a good relationship where she and the guy wanted to treat each other as equals. She doesn't want children either - not because she doesn't like kids; in fact, she likes them fine and acts as a mentor and protector to a girl for part of the book. She just doesn't want her own. And when on her travels she encounters women who are not sure how to protect themselves after their husbands or sons have disappeared (or whatever), she doesn't side with the many fantasy heroines who gripe about how useless those girls are. She wonders why people don't train their daughters in self-defense and force them to be dependent on others to protect themselves, which is not a foolproof system by a long shot. And being Katsa, you know she'll try to fix this, too.
Also, the villain was one of the scariest villains I've seen in a while, and he wasn't quite typical either. He didn't live in a brooding fortress, or ride into battle, or go around randomly stabbing peasants to show us how evil he is, or spend piles of gold on gluttonous feasts and fancy clothes, or even bribe people to hide his evil deeds.
I also enjoyed the prequel, Fire, and am looking forward to the release of the sequel Bitterblue.
Katsa is the king's enforcer/executioner. She hates the job and herself a bit for doing it, but at the beginning doesn't see how to break free of his control. So in her spare time, she's formed a secret council that does good deeds under cover of darkness in an attempt to undo some of the harm she and the king have done. A mission introduces her to Prince Po and a boatload of conspiracy and intrigue, which naturally leads to them going on a mission to find out the truth and possibly rescue a few people and topple a monarchy.
The Seven Kingdoms are like many Fantasylands with their vaguely medieval setups, but Cashore doesn't always follow the script, fortunately. Like many fantasy heroines, Katsa doesn't like wearing dresses - but only because they get in the way of her work, not because she thinks dresses are inherently evil creations. She quite likes her nurse, who is very much pro-dress. She doesn't want to get married - not because she hates men, but because the legal aspects of marriage in her society are unfair, and she thinks that would wreck even a good relationship where she and the guy wanted to treat each other as equals. She doesn't want children either - not because she doesn't like kids; in fact, she likes them fine and acts as a mentor and protector to a girl for part of the book. She just doesn't want her own. And when on her travels she encounters women who are not sure how to protect themselves after their husbands or sons have disappeared (or whatever), she doesn't side with the many fantasy heroines who gripe about how useless those girls are. She wonders why people don't train their daughters in self-defense and force them to be dependent on others to protect themselves, which is not a foolproof system by a long shot. And being Katsa, you know she'll try to fix this, too.
Also, the villain was one of the scariest villains I've seen in a while, and he wasn't quite typical either. He didn't live in a brooding fortress, or ride into battle, or go around randomly stabbing peasants to show us how evil he is, or spend piles of gold on gluttonous feasts and fancy clothes, or even bribe people to hide his evil deeds.
I also enjoyed the prequel, Fire, and am looking forward to the release of the sequel Bitterblue.
I loved this book! I truly didn't want it to end. I'd love to write more, but busy, busy, busy. Oh, and I loved the narration. Some of the music in the background was a little too much, but I loved having different voices for the characters.
i thought the book was amazing and beautifully written.
Excellent!
Like many novels there is a point or two where the story seems to slow too much for some readers but I truly enjoyed the key character, Katsa, who has a talent for fighting, combat, and killing. That talent is used by her uncle to punish and/or destroy those who disagree or disobey him. For her uncle, it is important not just to kill but often to torture before killing. Her distaste for torture leads Katsa to refuse to follow his instructions putting her in a difficult position.
Many characters in this novel are "graced" with skills that make their life more interesting or difficult depending upon how you look at it. One is Po, whose grandfather has been kidnapped. When Katsa decides to help him their adventures begin and they narrowly escape difficult situation after difficult situation.
They fall in love but Katsa is determined not to marry anyone. As the novel develops, the reader supports the formation of the Council, an underground network of innkeepers, servants, and gracelings, who share knowledge to thwart missions and protect the innocent who inadvertently encounter the fickle judgment of rulers like Katsa's uncle, Randa.
This is an excellent beginning to a well written series. I hope, however, that the author avoids the trap of many authors who write series and use weak plots and extended wordage just to get the next novel out.
Like many novels there is a point or two where the story seems to slow too much for some readers but I truly enjoyed the key character, Katsa, who has a talent for fighting, combat, and killing. That talent is used by her uncle to punish and/or destroy those who disagree or disobey him. For her uncle, it is important not just to kill but often to torture before killing. Her distaste for torture leads Katsa to refuse to follow his instructions putting her in a difficult position.
Many characters in this novel are "graced" with skills that make their life more interesting or difficult depending upon how you look at it. One is Po, whose grandfather has been kidnapped. When Katsa decides to help him their adventures begin and they narrowly escape difficult situation after difficult situation.
They fall in love but Katsa is determined not to marry anyone. As the novel develops, the reader supports the formation of the Council, an underground network of innkeepers, servants, and gracelings, who share knowledge to thwart missions and protect the innocent who inadvertently encounter the fickle judgment of rulers like Katsa's uncle, Randa.
This is an excellent beginning to a well written series. I hope, however, that the author avoids the trap of many authors who write series and use weak plots and extended wordage just to get the next novel out.
I really loved this book. It was uniquely done. The idea that someone could be born with a "Grace" like the individuals in this story was really interesting. I kept turning the pages to see what was going to happen next. The story line kept me on a roller coaster. There was so much I wanted to happen, that did not, yet so much that did happen that was so good that I was enthralled with the story line. I felt sorry for young Bitterblue and so very glad that there are two more novels. I hope the next two books are as amazing as this one was. I can't wait to read them.
