Karen S. (MKSbooklady) reviewed An Impartial Witness (Bess Crawford, Bk 2) on + 989 more book reviews
Helpful Score: 1
Started out running, the mystery unfolds in the first few pages, and goes from there, but I thought the middle dragged on some, and I found myself wishing this book was about 50 pages shorter.
Shana R. (LynniePennie) reviewed An Impartial Witness (Bess Crawford, Bk 2) on + 169 more book reviews
I haven't read a good mystery in a long time. For a change I picked this book as one of my Amazon Vine selections. This is the second of the author's new series. The amateur sleuth here is Bess Crawford. Bess is a very compassionate nurse who works very close to the front lines during WWI. One of the soldiers she was treating held his wife's photo near him at all times. When Bess is on leave she witnesses this soldiers wife very upset in what seems to be a compromising position. When the soldiers wife ends up being murdered that exact day Bess sets out to figure out what happened to her.
I was a little worried that by first reading the second of the series that I'd be lost. That wasn't the case. You should be able to pick this up and get to know Bess just like if you had read the first of this series.
The mystery here isn't too difficult to figure out, but that didn't bother me. I enjoyed following Bess' journey and wondering just how she would figure out who had done it. This book reminds a little of a grown-up Nancy Drew type mystery or a cozy mystery. There's really no explicit language or compromising positions here, which was nice for a change.
One of the only things I wished for in the storyline was for more details of how and why the victim and her attackers relationship started. I felt like I just needed to know this to understand the victims emotions when Bess saw her before she was murdered. I didn't think the reasons given where really developed enough.
Overall, I'd give this one a 4.5 or 5 as I rather enjoyed it. It's not a brainteaser or spine-tingler at all just a good mystery to set down with for tea.
I was a little worried that by first reading the second of the series that I'd be lost. That wasn't the case. You should be able to pick this up and get to know Bess just like if you had read the first of this series.
The mystery here isn't too difficult to figure out, but that didn't bother me. I enjoyed following Bess' journey and wondering just how she would figure out who had done it. This book reminds a little of a grown-up Nancy Drew type mystery or a cozy mystery. There's really no explicit language or compromising positions here, which was nice for a change.
One of the only things I wished for in the storyline was for more details of how and why the victim and her attackers relationship started. I felt like I just needed to know this to understand the victims emotions when Bess saw her before she was murdered. I didn't think the reasons given where really developed enough.
Overall, I'd give this one a 4.5 or 5 as I rather enjoyed it. It's not a brainteaser or spine-tingler at all just a good mystery to set down with for tea.
Cathy C. (cathyskye) -
First Line: As my train pulled into London, I looked out at the early summer rain and was glad to see the dreary day had followed me from Hampshire.
It is the early summer of 1917 and nurse Bess Crawford has returned to England from France with a convoy of gravely wounded soldiers. One of the men is a badly burned young pilot who wears a photo of his wife pinned to his tunic. He clings to life solely because of his love for her.
In a London train station Bess happens to witness the extremely emotional farewell between a woman and an officer. When the woman turns her head, Bess recognizes her. She is the wife of the young, burned pilot, which means that the officer is most definitely not her husband.
Back in France, Bess happens to see a newspaper article in which Scotland Yard is asking for any information about the woman in the sketch. The sketch is of the pilot's wife, the woman at the train station. Bess feels that she must become involved in the case because of the young pilot's love for his wife and because of the fact that she seems to be the last person to see the woman alive. It won't be long at all before Bess realizes just how dangerous her quest for the truth really is.
For me, the enjoyment in reading the books in this series comes not from deducing the murderer, but from immersing myself in the time period and in the character of Bess herself. Living in an era (as I do) in which it seems no one wants to claim responsibility for anything, Bess's sense of duty and responsibility is quite refreshing. She may have a stubborn and slightly reckless streak, but she's got an excellent safety net in her family-- and she knows how to use her common sense.
The mother-son writing duo known as Charles Todd has a long-running series set in the same era which centers around Ian Rutledge, a shell-shocked veteran who returns to his job at Scotland Yard. That series is also very good, but after a while, I tired of Rutledge being haunted by the ill-tempered spirit of a soldier shot for desertion.
Bess has no such haunts, for which I am grateful, and it seems that, if she finally becomes aware of someone right underneath her nose, she may have a relationship to help keep her grounded in future books. I like Bess, and I look forward to reading more books in the series to see if I'm right about her prospects.
If you've read Todd's Ian Rutledge series or Jacqueline Winspear's Maisie Dobbs series about a former World War I nurse as private investigator in 1930's London, you should enjoy this series about Bess Crawford.
It is the early summer of 1917 and nurse Bess Crawford has returned to England from France with a convoy of gravely wounded soldiers. One of the men is a badly burned young pilot who wears a photo of his wife pinned to his tunic. He clings to life solely because of his love for her.
In a London train station Bess happens to witness the extremely emotional farewell between a woman and an officer. When the woman turns her head, Bess recognizes her. She is the wife of the young, burned pilot, which means that the officer is most definitely not her husband.
Back in France, Bess happens to see a newspaper article in which Scotland Yard is asking for any information about the woman in the sketch. The sketch is of the pilot's wife, the woman at the train station. Bess feels that she must become involved in the case because of the young pilot's love for his wife and because of the fact that she seems to be the last person to see the woman alive. It won't be long at all before Bess realizes just how dangerous her quest for the truth really is.
For me, the enjoyment in reading the books in this series comes not from deducing the murderer, but from immersing myself in the time period and in the character of Bess herself. Living in an era (as I do) in which it seems no one wants to claim responsibility for anything, Bess's sense of duty and responsibility is quite refreshing. She may have a stubborn and slightly reckless streak, but she's got an excellent safety net in her family-- and she knows how to use her common sense.
The mother-son writing duo known as Charles Todd has a long-running series set in the same era which centers around Ian Rutledge, a shell-shocked veteran who returns to his job at Scotland Yard. That series is also very good, but after a while, I tired of Rutledge being haunted by the ill-tempered spirit of a soldier shot for desertion.
Bess has no such haunts, for which I am grateful, and it seems that, if she finally becomes aware of someone right underneath her nose, she may have a relationship to help keep her grounded in future books. I like Bess, and I look forward to reading more books in the series to see if I'm right about her prospects.
If you've read Todd's Ian Rutledge series or Jacqueline Winspear's Maisie Dobbs series about a former World War I nurse as private investigator in 1930's London, you should enjoy this series about Bess Crawford.
Carolyn A. (carolynalt) reviewed An Impartial Witness (Bess Crawford, Bk 2) on + 37 more book reviews
This series is set during WW1. Women were doing all kinds of new things---driving cars, nursing on the battlefields. Bess Crawford is one of these women. She's smart and strong and curious. This is a good, believable story in a good, believable series. Recommended by me!
Cheryl R. (Spuddie) -
This review applies to the audio version.
#2 Bess Crawford historical mystery set during WWI in England. Bess, a nurse, is escorting several patients back to a care facility in England from the battles in France. While she is at the train station making her own way back to London for a quick twenty-four hour leave, she recognizes a woman on the platform as Mrs. Evenson--the wife of one of the severely burned men she has just deposited. He carried her picture with him all the time, so Bess would be hard-pressed NOT to recognize her.
But troublingly, the woman was crying and talking to another man--an officer in the Wiltshire Division. The scene disturbed her, but not as much as reading a newspaper article about her murder several weeks later when back in France--the newspaper was already old, being in a care package for one of her co-workers from home. Police are asking anyone who saw the woman on the day of her disappearance to help with enquiries, and Bess writes Scotland Yard to share her experience. They summon her back to England to speak with them and through other coincidences gets involved in helping solve the case with her amateur sleuthing.
I rather liked the first book of this series, but this one I just could not get interested in. Bess seems rather devolved as a character, and it's hard for me to say that I know her very well--she's all over the place with regards to her thoughts, actions, emotions, etc. The mystery was rather obvious and I couldn't say that I felt particularly immersed in the time and place either--some parts felt kind of superficial where it seemed things should have been explored in depth, and other things that I felt were side issues were dwelt upon overly much.
The book was competently read, although the reader had a couple of annoying habits--but honestly, I don't think it made a difference to my opinion about the book itself. I finished this, but honestly I think I will just stop here in this series.
#2 Bess Crawford historical mystery set during WWI in England. Bess, a nurse, is escorting several patients back to a care facility in England from the battles in France. While she is at the train station making her own way back to London for a quick twenty-four hour leave, she recognizes a woman on the platform as Mrs. Evenson--the wife of one of the severely burned men she has just deposited. He carried her picture with him all the time, so Bess would be hard-pressed NOT to recognize her.
But troublingly, the woman was crying and talking to another man--an officer in the Wiltshire Division. The scene disturbed her, but not as much as reading a newspaper article about her murder several weeks later when back in France--the newspaper was already old, being in a care package for one of her co-workers from home. Police are asking anyone who saw the woman on the day of her disappearance to help with enquiries, and Bess writes Scotland Yard to share her experience. They summon her back to England to speak with them and through other coincidences gets involved in helping solve the case with her amateur sleuthing.
I rather liked the first book of this series, but this one I just could not get interested in. Bess seems rather devolved as a character, and it's hard for me to say that I know her very well--she's all over the place with regards to her thoughts, actions, emotions, etc. The mystery was rather obvious and I couldn't say that I felt particularly immersed in the time and place either--some parts felt kind of superficial where it seemed things should have been explored in depth, and other things that I felt were side issues were dwelt upon overly much.
The book was competently read, although the reader had a couple of annoying habits--but honestly, I don't think it made a difference to my opinion about the book itself. I finished this, but honestly I think I will just stop here in this series.
Thomas F. (hardtack) -
While I enjoyed this mystery, I felt it dragged on a bit too long. Perhaps it was because I identified the murderer early on. I kept trying to tell Miss Crawford, and the Scotland Yard Inspector, who it was, but neither of them would listen to me.
Well, if they're too snoody to take my advice, they can do without my help in the future. However, I'll keep reading this series, if only to see how they stumble over themselves. :-)
Well, if they're too snoody to take my advice, they can do without my help in the future. However, I'll keep reading this series, if only to see how they stumble over themselves. :-)
