LecClier K. (SierraK) -
Helpful Score: 5
A lonely old man named Holberg is found murdered in his apartment. When Reyjavik Polic Inspector Erlendur looks into the crime, he discovers the victim had been accused of rape thirty years ago but never convicted. Erlendur tracks down very old clues to try to solve Holberg's murder.
I really enjoyed the characters and the Iceland setting. Looking forward to reading more books from this author.
I really enjoyed the characters and the Iceland setting. Looking forward to reading more books from this author.
Susan R. (suzyshadow) reviewed Jar City (aka Tainted Blood) (Reykjavik, Bk 1) on + 125 more book reviews
Helpful Score: 4
This was one of the best and most interesting books I've read in a long time. Knowing nothing about Iceland, I found the descriptions of the climate, the countryside, the rain all very interesting. The story is well plotted but very dark...don't expect to feel good about anything that happens. It is definitely a good read.
Cheryl R. (Spuddie) -
Helpful Score: 3
Icelandic police procedural featuring detective named Erlandur--that's his first name, since most Icelanders go only by their first names, even in the phone book, apparently! An elderly man is found bludgeoned to death in his basement flat and that begins to unravel a whole parcel of strange facts that set Erlandur off on several different tangents. Apparently his detective's nose is accurate though because his instincts prove right. A sad, heartbreaking tale set in a very interesting backdrop of Iceland, which I know next to nothing about. Excellently written, difficult to put down, with a new character to love. I felt that Erlandur was very well fleshed out, but I hope the author plumps up his co-workers and his family members more next time around. Looking for the next one!
Vivian Q. (bellasgranny) -
Helpful Score: 3
The first book, in a series which takes place in Iceland, was terrific and a great opener for the books that follow. I rediscovered my interest in Scandinavian crime fiction after following a thread on Amazon for a few weeks. I remember reading Sjowall and Wahloo in the 70s and this was a wonderful reintroduction to the genre. Terrific characters, setting and translation. I highly recommend.
Helpful Score: 1
Currently reading and thoroughly mesmerized by this book ! Am now an addicted Indridason reader ( read 2 other title thus far) and his sense of place and culture, depth of character analysis and mystery on many levels makes for absorbing and thought-provoking reading.
Helpful Score: 1
Just when I thought there couldn't possibly be any more good Scandinavian detective writers ...
I highly recommend this Icelandic police procedural. It's well written, plotted, and paced. The characters are beautifully drawn and the local color plays an integral part in the unfolding drama. Don't ask what the title means ... all will be revealed in time.
The author's middle-aged, stressed-out, world-weary homicide detective (with personal problems just a tad better than those suffered by his customers) takes an honored place in a long line of similar protagonists. I will happily dig in to the other books in this series.
I highly recommend this Icelandic police procedural. It's well written, plotted, and paced. The characters are beautifully drawn and the local color plays an integral part in the unfolding drama. Don't ask what the title means ... all will be revealed in time.
The author's middle-aged, stressed-out, world-weary homicide detective (with personal problems just a tad better than those suffered by his customers) takes an honored place in a long line of similar protagonists. I will happily dig in to the other books in this series.
Aging detective grapples with bizarre case while struggling to connect with troubled adult daughter in this unusual tale.
Joan W. (justreadingabook) reviewed Jar City (aka Tainted Blood) (Reykjavik, Bk 1) on + 1728 more book reviews
This was an excellent book. A old man is found murdered and his past is anything but pleasant. No details or friends. Building a case and finding the murderer is Erlendur's job.
A Icelandic detective with a drive for the truth.
Different layers of characters and details make this a joy to read. Hard to find storylines like these.
Heading to get the next book.
A Icelandic detective with a drive for the truth.
Different layers of characters and details make this a joy to read. Hard to find storylines like these.
Heading to get the next book.
Frank S. (colonelstech) reviewed Jar City (aka Tainted Blood) (Reykjavik, Bk 1) on + 38 more book reviews
New Crimes, Old Solutions, June 19, 2013 By
Dr. Frank Stech
Arnaldur Indridason, author of the Reykjavik Murder Mysteries, began the series with "Jar City" (also published as "Tainted Blood"). I read this novel after having read Indridason's "Artic Chill," the fifth of the series. His characters appear to evolve hardly at all. Indridason's main protagonist is Inspector Ehrlendur, who shares enough character flaws to be Martin Beck's fraternal twin and Kurt Wallandar's cousin: badly failed marriage, alcohol and/or tobacco addictions, troubled offspring wrestling with their own criminal and drug issues, bi-polar relationships with murder squad colleagues, borderline insubordination with police authorities -- you get the picture.
Like the Martin Beck, Kurt Wallander, and other ScandiNoir police procedural mystery series, Indridason's supporting cast (Detectives Elinborg and Sigurdur Oli) is colorful, but not nearly as entertaining and frustrating as Wallander's or Beck's fellow cops. (But then who could be as interesting as Gunwald Larrson?) Icelanders probably just aren't as jolly and carefree as those happy-go-lucky Swedes.
Inspector Ehrlendur has a 70 year old murder victim with an unsavory history of forty-year-old crimes, including rape. Titling the book "Tainted Blood" dumb-downs the suspense significantly; "Jar City" was a far better and far more artistic title.
No TV CSI magic here, no Sherlock geniuses, just gritty murder investigation. Ehrlendur and his crew do their detecting with good old-fashioned police procedures: shoe-leather interviews, victim analyses, crime scene forensics, developing leads and following up, repeating this over and over until they form cloudy hypotheses, then investigating still more to crystallize them.
Set all this police work against the foul, gloomy, cold, dark, wet Iceland background, and you can feel icy rain running down the back of your collar as the Reykjavik murder cops link new and old deaths and crimes. Cold cases indeed.
Indridason has a real knack for letting us slowly piece together the edges and corners of the jigsaw, sometimes ahead of, sometimes behind, Inspector Ehrlendur and his crew. But we are hardly ever ready for the dark philosophical paradoxes at the center of the puzzle. This talented mystery writer digs up these deep conundrums along with the corpses, then lays out these parables on the pathology table. Indridason forces us to examine and dissect, trying to understand the human conditions that lead to and stem from tainted blood and foul murder.
Dr. Frank Stech
Arnaldur Indridason, author of the Reykjavik Murder Mysteries, began the series with "Jar City" (also published as "Tainted Blood"). I read this novel after having read Indridason's "Artic Chill," the fifth of the series. His characters appear to evolve hardly at all. Indridason's main protagonist is Inspector Ehrlendur, who shares enough character flaws to be Martin Beck's fraternal twin and Kurt Wallandar's cousin: badly failed marriage, alcohol and/or tobacco addictions, troubled offspring wrestling with their own criminal and drug issues, bi-polar relationships with murder squad colleagues, borderline insubordination with police authorities -- you get the picture.
Like the Martin Beck, Kurt Wallander, and other ScandiNoir police procedural mystery series, Indridason's supporting cast (Detectives Elinborg and Sigurdur Oli) is colorful, but not nearly as entertaining and frustrating as Wallander's or Beck's fellow cops. (But then who could be as interesting as Gunwald Larrson?) Icelanders probably just aren't as jolly and carefree as those happy-go-lucky Swedes.
Inspector Ehrlendur has a 70 year old murder victim with an unsavory history of forty-year-old crimes, including rape. Titling the book "Tainted Blood" dumb-downs the suspense significantly; "Jar City" was a far better and far more artistic title.
No TV CSI magic here, no Sherlock geniuses, just gritty murder investigation. Ehrlendur and his crew do their detecting with good old-fashioned police procedures: shoe-leather interviews, victim analyses, crime scene forensics, developing leads and following up, repeating this over and over until they form cloudy hypotheses, then investigating still more to crystallize them.
Set all this police work against the foul, gloomy, cold, dark, wet Iceland background, and you can feel icy rain running down the back of your collar as the Reykjavik murder cops link new and old deaths and crimes. Cold cases indeed.
Indridason has a real knack for letting us slowly piece together the edges and corners of the jigsaw, sometimes ahead of, sometimes behind, Inspector Ehrlendur and his crew. But we are hardly ever ready for the dark philosophical paradoxes at the center of the puzzle. This talented mystery writer digs up these deep conundrums along with the corpses, then lays out these parables on the pathology table. Indridason forces us to examine and dissect, trying to understand the human conditions that lead to and stem from tainted blood and foul murder.
A solid mystery with intriguing details about life in Iceland. Will definitely read more by this author.
Really excellent start to the series. I read it in one sitting.
Tammy W. (tammy60) -
Fantastic book! This is the first book I've read from this author and will be reading the rest of the series. Erlendur, the main character, is great. A laid back, but always in motion Detective. A great 'who dunit' with twists and turns in the investigation that will have you not wanting to put it down. Be prepared to loose sleep!
Maura (maura853) -
My second Inspector Erlandur novel, and now officially one of my new guilty pleasures.
Not really a "who dunnit" but more like a "why dunnit" and a "how dunnit," Indridason's detective Elendur doesn't so much solve the mystery as beat it to death with a stick, following every possible lead with a doggedness that requires Olympic-standard patience of both the reader and his long-suffering colleagues. Erlandur blindsides suspects/witness/innocent bystanders with seemingly pointless questions. He draws (reasonable) associations from his case with his own grim family dynamic, and the plight of his daughter, Eva Lind, drug addict on a stumbling road to recovery and now, heaven help us, mother to be. He nukes another microwave meal, and chain-smokes, in spite of the worrying pain in his chest. He drinks a lot of coffee.
Yes, Erlandur puts the added "grim" into grim Scandi-noir -- making Wallender look like a blessed little ray of sunshine, and British sad sacks like Vera, Inspector Banks, Rebus etc look like a bunch of comedians. (There are, I promise you, some moments of wry humor. Such moments are to be cherished.)
But what I find fascinating -- what I'm reading it for, and what will, I think, keep me reading on, in spite the less-than-elegant prose -- are the insights into a surprisingly alien culture right on the edge of Europe, a world very like the one our grandparents (great grandparents?) probably knew, in which your whole world was encompassed by a couple dozen square miles, and anything further might have been the far side of the moon -- you had heard of it, of course, but the idea that you might ever live or even visit there was almost like science fiction. A world where you knew everyone in that territory, and were probably related to half of them (at least at a "99th cousin, once removed" basis), and you knew, or at least had suspicions about, all of their dark, dirty secrets. And they know yours ...
Erlandur's current investigation plays out in this hothouse environment, and comes to a surprisingly moving conclusion in a world where a relatively small genetic gene pool has life and death consequences for both the guilty and the innocents. Good stuff!!
Not really a "who dunnit" but more like a "why dunnit" and a "how dunnit," Indridason's detective Elendur doesn't so much solve the mystery as beat it to death with a stick, following every possible lead with a doggedness that requires Olympic-standard patience of both the reader and his long-suffering colleagues. Erlandur blindsides suspects/witness/innocent bystanders with seemingly pointless questions. He draws (reasonable) associations from his case with his own grim family dynamic, and the plight of his daughter, Eva Lind, drug addict on a stumbling road to recovery and now, heaven help us, mother to be. He nukes another microwave meal, and chain-smokes, in spite of the worrying pain in his chest. He drinks a lot of coffee.
Yes, Erlandur puts the added "grim" into grim Scandi-noir -- making Wallender look like a blessed little ray of sunshine, and British sad sacks like Vera, Inspector Banks, Rebus etc look like a bunch of comedians. (There are, I promise you, some moments of wry humor. Such moments are to be cherished.)
But what I find fascinating -- what I'm reading it for, and what will, I think, keep me reading on, in spite the less-than-elegant prose -- are the insights into a surprisingly alien culture right on the edge of Europe, a world very like the one our grandparents (great grandparents?) probably knew, in which your whole world was encompassed by a couple dozen square miles, and anything further might have been the far side of the moon -- you had heard of it, of course, but the idea that you might ever live or even visit there was almost like science fiction. A world where you knew everyone in that territory, and were probably related to half of them (at least at a "99th cousin, once removed" basis), and you knew, or at least had suspicions about, all of their dark, dirty secrets. And they know yours ...
Erlandur's current investigation plays out in this hothouse environment, and comes to a surprisingly moving conclusion in a world where a relatively small genetic gene pool has life and death consequences for both the guilty and the innocents. Good stuff!!
An old man is found murdered in his flat, with the picture of a child's grave and a cryptic message. Inspector Erlendur uncovers that many years ago he raped a woman and fathered her child who died at an early age. The mother killed herself a few years later because of the grief of losing her daughter. So who else could have had a motive? Were there other women who finally took their revenge? Or was it one of the old man's buddies, who were just as bad as he was?
This is a very good who-done-it? The locale is Iceland, and the solution to the crime lies there.
This is a very good who-done-it? The locale is Iceland, and the solution to the crime lies there.
excellent book, my favorite of the north country detective stories, so far.
