Not one of her best books. I was disapointed. Rebecca A.
After reading 22 of Garlocks books, most of which are wonderful, this story is a real disappointment. Garlock is known for her characters-with-depth; here, she didnt seem to waste much ink creating characters that were multi-dimensional and interesting.
Probably the most exciting character was Caleb Morgan. However, he was finished by the end of the Prologue. After the strong build up of this youngest son, it was a shock when he was gone. None of the other characters seemed to receive as much attention.
By the ½ way point, I realized that I didnt really care about any of the characters in this book. The premise of the story was neither logical nor interesting. Hallie, Pearl and Mary were a strange combination; their friendship simply didnt ring true.
On the other hand: The villains seemed meaner than the protagonists were good; it made for one strange and unbalanced story.
This author is a master at creating a mood and making place descriptions sparkle. For example, all five books in the Dolan Brothers series bring small town living and the feel of the Depression years to life (with amazing clarity).
Here, the two towns where most of the action took place -- Whiskey Bend and Bison City -- seemed to be ugly spots in the road. They were places one would want to leave as quickly as possible.
It pains me to give such a negative review because I admire Dorothy Garlocks writing and storytelling skills. Shes been one of my favorite authors since discovering her some time ago. Any writer can have a book that doesnt speak to the reader and hopefully this is just a fluke.
Probably the most exciting character was Caleb Morgan. However, he was finished by the end of the Prologue. After the strong build up of this youngest son, it was a shock when he was gone. None of the other characters seemed to receive as much attention.
By the ½ way point, I realized that I didnt really care about any of the characters in this book. The premise of the story was neither logical nor interesting. Hallie, Pearl and Mary were a strange combination; their friendship simply didnt ring true.
On the other hand: The villains seemed meaner than the protagonists were good; it made for one strange and unbalanced story.
This author is a master at creating a mood and making place descriptions sparkle. For example, all five books in the Dolan Brothers series bring small town living and the feel of the Depression years to life (with amazing clarity).
Here, the two towns where most of the action took place -- Whiskey Bend and Bison City -- seemed to be ugly spots in the road. They were places one would want to leave as quickly as possible.
It pains me to give such a negative review because I admire Dorothy Garlocks writing and storytelling skills. Shes been one of my favorite authors since discovering her some time ago. Any writer can have a book that doesnt speak to the reader and hopefully this is just a fluke.
For me this wasn't bad but it wasn't good either just middle of the road...blah....Story seemed to drag on while telling me nothing while at the same time feeling rushed to get from A - The End. Parts just felt forced and did not flow smoothly..."Kinda like my review". On the plus side I loved the character of Abe =) He cracked me up!
I love Dorothy Garlock's book, but this book seemed to go on forever. Dorothy has a wonderful way of making the characters come alive and you get the feeling of being right in the middle of the action.
About half way through the book, the excitement was gone.
About half way through the book, the excitement was gone.
Very good book...I did enjoy it but then I always enjoy Dorothy Garlock.
After reading 22 of Garlocks books, most of which are wonderful, this story is a real disappointment. Garlock is known for her characters-with-depth; here, she didnt seem to waste much ink creating characters that were multi-dimensional and interesting.
Probably the most exciting character was Caleb Morgan. However, he was finished by the end of the Prologue. After the strong build up of this youngest son, it was a shock when he was gone. None of the other characters seemed to receive as much attention.
By the ½ way point, I realized that I didnt really care about any of the characters in this book. The premise of the story was neither logical nor interesting. Hallie, Pearl and Mary were a strange combination; their friendship simply didnt ring true.
On the other hand: The villains seemed meaner than the protagonists were good; it made for one strange and unbalanced story.
This author is a master at creating a mood and making place descriptions sparkle. For example, all five books in the Dolan Brothers series bring small town living and the feel of the Depression years to life (with amazing clarity).
Here, the two towns where most of the action took place -- Whiskey Bend and Bison City -- seemed to be ugly spots in the road. They were places one would want to leave as quickly as possible.
It pains me to give such a negative review because I admire Dorothy Garlocks writing and storytelling skills. Shes been one of my favorite authors since discovering her some time ago. Any writer can have a book that doesnt speak to the reader and hopefully this is just a fluke.
Probably the most exciting character was Caleb Morgan. However, he was finished by the end of the Prologue. After the strong build up of this youngest son, it was a shock when he was gone. None of the other characters seemed to receive as much attention.
By the ½ way point, I realized that I didnt really care about any of the characters in this book. The premise of the story was neither logical nor interesting. Hallie, Pearl and Mary were a strange combination; their friendship simply didnt ring true.
On the other hand: The villains seemed meaner than the protagonists were good; it made for one strange and unbalanced story.
This author is a master at creating a mood and making place descriptions sparkle. For example, all five books in the Dolan Brothers series bring small town living and the feel of the Depression years to life (with amazing clarity).
Here, the two towns where most of the action took place -- Whiskey Bend and Bison City -- seemed to be ugly spots in the road. They were places one would want to leave as quickly as possible.
It pains me to give such a negative review because I admire Dorothy Garlocks writing and storytelling skills. Shes been one of my favorite authors since discovering her some time ago. Any writer can have a book that doesnt speak to the reader and hopefully this is just a fluke.
