Helpful Score: 7
I adore her writing on her LiveJournal and this is urban fantasy with much more developed fae world that I've ever seen - there are rose goblins and cait sidhe and undines and hobs and all sorts of fae in here. Most other urban fantasy takes one or two of the more well-known types and only makes mention of the rest. This level of detail shouldn't surprise anyone who has even the vaguest idea of what-all goes on inside Seanan's head - it's a very busy place.
When I think about other urban fantasy, specifically the fae-world-alongside-our-own kind, they pretty much all use a clueles POV character - that way the author can explain things about faerie to them and hence to us. But Toby is an integral part of this world from the get-go. She has a life, a family, a history, etc. - all richly intertwined with the lives of the fae whe interacts with. After a very brief set-up in a prologue, we are basically dropped down in the middle of this and just expected to keep up as best we can. I suspect that this will make for the best kind of re-read; the kind where you find new things or connect new dots that you didn't notice the first time.
I confess to occasionally stopping to giggle at a particularly Seanan-esque turn of phrase, like "That's unexpected. And kind of insane." or "He gave me the sort of look usually reserved for people with contagious diseases and unpaid bills." or even "I'm a Selkie. We drown people semi-professionally". Also, I kind of want a pet rose goblin now. (and I knew when he said he called but hadn't).
I look forward to re-reading this, as well as tagging along on Toby's next adventure (while safely out of gunshot range). We only have to wait 6 more months.
When I think about other urban fantasy, specifically the fae-world-alongside-our-own kind, they pretty much all use a clueles POV character - that way the author can explain things about faerie to them and hence to us. But Toby is an integral part of this world from the get-go. She has a life, a family, a history, etc. - all richly intertwined with the lives of the fae whe interacts with. After a very brief set-up in a prologue, we are basically dropped down in the middle of this and just expected to keep up as best we can. I suspect that this will make for the best kind of re-read; the kind where you find new things or connect new dots that you didn't notice the first time.
I confess to occasionally stopping to giggle at a particularly Seanan-esque turn of phrase, like "That's unexpected. And kind of insane." or "He gave me the sort of look usually reserved for people with contagious diseases and unpaid bills." or even "I'm a Selkie. We drown people semi-professionally". Also, I kind of want a pet rose goblin now. (and I knew when he said he called but hadn't).
I look forward to re-reading this, as well as tagging along on Toby's next adventure (while safely out of gunshot range). We only have to wait 6 more months.
Helpful Score: 5
I love books about the fairy world mingling with our world. Since I haven't been all the thrilled with the Meredith Gentry books lately, I was excited to start another series that deals with the fairy world. There are a number of young adult series out there that deal with the fairy world but not many adult novels. This ended up being a pretty good book. I think this series has a lot of promise.
October Daye is a changeling, half human half fairy. She is also a Knight of the fairy realms and has a daughter and a human boyfriend. At least she had those things until she made a fatal mistake and was changed into a koi fish for fourteen years. When she returns to the human world everything has changed for her, her daughter won't see her, her investigation business has been sold off and she has been declared dead. In her new life she has one goal, to never deal with fairy again. Unfortunately her new goal will not be realized. She receives a call from a prominent fairy noble named Evening. Evening is in trouble and she magically binds October to figure out what is going on. Now October is thrust back into the fairy world and she must solve Evening's murder; if she doesn't her life is forfeit.
There's a lot to like in this book. The world McGuire has created is complex, detailed, and very believable. It is focused mainly on the city of San Francisco and surrounding California, but does look like it could easily be expanded to wider horizons. The characterization is another strong point. The characters are believable, unique, have intriguing pasts, and are not always good or evil but a mix of both. These characters are fascinating and that extends to the side characters as well as the main ones.
There are some wonderful action scenes in this book. McGuire does an excellent job with these. The plot is fast moving and very engaging. The book was hard to put down, you always wonder what is going to happen to October next and if she will be successful in solving the murder. This is definitely not a romance book, but an action packed urban fantasy. Although October is not an action hero or a super hero; she is more of an ordinary everyday girl trying to make a living but constantly getting thrust into extraordinary situations.
McGuire did an excellent job of keeping October focused on her goals. I hate it when the heroine gets so scattered and distracted that she doesn't know what she's doing; that didn't happen in this book. McGuire also did an excellent job of bringing the main storyline in this book to a close; while leaving some threads hanging for the next book. Another nice thing was how McGuire summarized what October needs to focus on in the next book at the end of this book. I appreciated the pronunciation guide included as well. It would have been nice to have a Glossary to help you keep all the fairy races straight.
There were a couple of things that I didn't like about the book. Personally I didn't like October as much as a character. She spent a lot of the beginning of the book trying to shrug off her responsibilities; she also does a lot of stupid things throughout the book. I also wasn't a huge fan of McGuire's overall writing style. At times it didn't seem to flow all that well for me and it was a bit difficult to read. This is a pretty small quibble, but there are some books out there that are absolutely effortless to read they are so natural and this wasn't one of those books for me. Lastly you get a lot of different types of fairies thrown at you right away. McGuire is inconsistent about describing these different races, sometimes she does and sometimes you are left to struggle through it on your own. This is another reason why a index or glossary of fairy races would have been nice.
Overall I liked the book. I think this could be the start of a magnificent series. Like many first books, this one could have used a little more polish, but the main elements are there. Mcguire is very good at world-building and characterization and writes some awesome action scenes. I am looking forward to reading the next book "A Local Habitation" due out in March 2010.
October Daye is a changeling, half human half fairy. She is also a Knight of the fairy realms and has a daughter and a human boyfriend. At least she had those things until she made a fatal mistake and was changed into a koi fish for fourteen years. When she returns to the human world everything has changed for her, her daughter won't see her, her investigation business has been sold off and she has been declared dead. In her new life she has one goal, to never deal with fairy again. Unfortunately her new goal will not be realized. She receives a call from a prominent fairy noble named Evening. Evening is in trouble and she magically binds October to figure out what is going on. Now October is thrust back into the fairy world and she must solve Evening's murder; if she doesn't her life is forfeit.
There's a lot to like in this book. The world McGuire has created is complex, detailed, and very believable. It is focused mainly on the city of San Francisco and surrounding California, but does look like it could easily be expanded to wider horizons. The characterization is another strong point. The characters are believable, unique, have intriguing pasts, and are not always good or evil but a mix of both. These characters are fascinating and that extends to the side characters as well as the main ones.
There are some wonderful action scenes in this book. McGuire does an excellent job with these. The plot is fast moving and very engaging. The book was hard to put down, you always wonder what is going to happen to October next and if she will be successful in solving the murder. This is definitely not a romance book, but an action packed urban fantasy. Although October is not an action hero or a super hero; she is more of an ordinary everyday girl trying to make a living but constantly getting thrust into extraordinary situations.
McGuire did an excellent job of keeping October focused on her goals. I hate it when the heroine gets so scattered and distracted that she doesn't know what she's doing; that didn't happen in this book. McGuire also did an excellent job of bringing the main storyline in this book to a close; while leaving some threads hanging for the next book. Another nice thing was how McGuire summarized what October needs to focus on in the next book at the end of this book. I appreciated the pronunciation guide included as well. It would have been nice to have a Glossary to help you keep all the fairy races straight.
There were a couple of things that I didn't like about the book. Personally I didn't like October as much as a character. She spent a lot of the beginning of the book trying to shrug off her responsibilities; she also does a lot of stupid things throughout the book. I also wasn't a huge fan of McGuire's overall writing style. At times it didn't seem to flow all that well for me and it was a bit difficult to read. This is a pretty small quibble, but there are some books out there that are absolutely effortless to read they are so natural and this wasn't one of those books for me. Lastly you get a lot of different types of fairies thrown at you right away. McGuire is inconsistent about describing these different races, sometimes she does and sometimes you are left to struggle through it on your own. This is another reason why a index or glossary of fairy races would have been nice.
Overall I liked the book. I think this could be the start of a magnificent series. Like many first books, this one could have used a little more polish, but the main elements are there. Mcguire is very good at world-building and characterization and writes some awesome action scenes. I am looking forward to reading the next book "A Local Habitation" due out in March 2010.
Helpful Score: 1
I find it interesting that most of the reviews for this book are quite lengthy. I think it's because so much happens, there is so much detail, that it's hard to describe in just a few words. I fell into both Rosemary and Rue and its sequel, A Local Habitation, at the very first page and reluctantly surfaced at the end. This is a marvelous series and I can't wait for the next installment. Two of the best books I've read in a very long time.
Helpful Score: 1
Rating: 5 out of 5 stars
Review: I very much enjoyed this book. Once I started reading it I couldn't set it down. The world that McGuire built is very absorbing and interesting. I'm always a fan of series that reach back to traditional Celtic mythology.
The main character, October (Tobe) Daye is a changeling - half-fey, half-human. Aside from an early idyllic childhood life's been rough on her, though she had always managed to find her way out on top eventually. However, her latest adventure was just too much for her. She had been hired by her friend and liege lord to track his brother and find where the brother was keeping the liege lord's wife and daughter. Unfortunately, things went very wrong and she spent 14 years as a fish. Once she returned to normal she withdrew from everyone that she had known previously and tried to live her life as much like a normal human as possible. However, she's dragged back into the fey world by the death of a long acquaintance/friend of hers, and more specifically by that friend binder her to find the friend's killer.
The story is engrossing, and I love all the different characters we meet along the way.
The biggest problem I have with the book is that Tobe is a little too weak - she doesn't have much magic, and despite the fact that she's supposedly a very good PI, we don't see any evidence of that in this book. Instead she stumbles around from clue to clue until the solution is shoved in her face. To her benefit, it was shoved in her face by people that she had asked for help. I'm also willing to write her apparent lack of investigations skills off to 14 years of rustiness and the fact that she hadn't really been living or thinking until the binding forced her to rejoin the rest of the world.
Despite that problem with the character, I absolutely loved this book and went out and bought the 2nd book in this series as soon as I finished this one.
Review: I very much enjoyed this book. Once I started reading it I couldn't set it down. The world that McGuire built is very absorbing and interesting. I'm always a fan of series that reach back to traditional Celtic mythology.
The main character, October (Tobe) Daye is a changeling - half-fey, half-human. Aside from an early idyllic childhood life's been rough on her, though she had always managed to find her way out on top eventually. However, her latest adventure was just too much for her. She had been hired by her friend and liege lord to track his brother and find where the brother was keeping the liege lord's wife and daughter. Unfortunately, things went very wrong and she spent 14 years as a fish. Once she returned to normal she withdrew from everyone that she had known previously and tried to live her life as much like a normal human as possible. However, she's dragged back into the fey world by the death of a long acquaintance/friend of hers, and more specifically by that friend binder her to find the friend's killer.
The story is engrossing, and I love all the different characters we meet along the way.
The biggest problem I have with the book is that Tobe is a little too weak - she doesn't have much magic, and despite the fact that she's supposedly a very good PI, we don't see any evidence of that in this book. Instead she stumbles around from clue to clue until the solution is shoved in her face. To her benefit, it was shoved in her face by people that she had asked for help. I'm also willing to write her apparent lack of investigations skills off to 14 years of rustiness and the fact that she hadn't really been living or thinking until the binding forced her to rejoin the rest of the world.
Despite that problem with the character, I absolutely loved this book and went out and bought the 2nd book in this series as soon as I finished this one.
Helpful Score: 1
Incredible world building, but there was so much loss for October that sometimes I had a hard time getting myself to pick the book up again. She loses her family of origin, her career, her husband, her daughter, 14 years of her life... I get it that urban fantasy is supposed to be dark, but I'm sticking with LL Foster and Patricia Briggs who give you a little happiness to go along with it.
Helpful Score: 1
I started the book and wasn't too crazy about it, but as I got into it I liked it more.
Ms McGuire has put a lot of effort into creating her urban fantasy world. It appears to me she developed it before she started writing the book. I love all the odd creatures. The murder mystery was pretty good too. I will definately read the second book.
Ms McGuire has put a lot of effort into creating her urban fantasy world. It appears to me she developed it before she started writing the book. I love all the odd creatures. The murder mystery was pretty good too. I will definately read the second book.
Helpful Score: 1
Very descriptive view of fae kingdoms and inhabitants. October "Toby" Daye is a changeling with half fae and half human blood. A former PI, she know tries to survive in the human world by working nights in a grocery store. A sudden death throws her back into the fae world. Although I enjoyed this book, I really wanted it to grab me and keep me enthralled. It never quite hit that feeling. 3 stars
Helpful Score: 1
I did like this book. I thought the main character, October Daye was great. If it seemed that she was shrugging off her responsibilities, it's because in the beginning of the story, she lost 14 years of her life as well as her daughter and fiance who, 14 years later wish to have nothing at all to do with her. This is also the beginning of a series of books and I love that we'll be able to see her grow and regain any integrity and honor she might have lost during those years.
A fun start to a series! The plot is a little thin, but that's hard to notice with the extensive world building and the in-depth introductions to the characters that populate that world.
After 14 years as a fish, October "Toby" Daye escapes the enchantment only to become a recluse afraid to rejoin the world she inhabited before capture. She is reluctantly pulled back into the world of Fae by a telephone call which puts a curse on her to find a friends killer or die herself. As typically happens when dealing with the Fae, nothing is as it appears. Friends aren't really friends and enemies aren't really enemies. The surprises keep coming and definitely keep Toby on her feet. Though nothing stops the assassins from shooting her because whoever killed her friend is now after her.
The twists are surprising and the betrayals are heart-breaking. Toby is a reluctant hero who is once again back on her game. If you enjoy Patricia Briggs Mercy Thompson series or Julie Kagawa's Iron Fey, you will definitely like this series as well.
The twists are surprising and the betrayals are heart-breaking. Toby is a reluctant hero who is once again back on her game. If you enjoy Patricia Briggs Mercy Thompson series or Julie Kagawa's Iron Fey, you will definitely like this series as well.
Rosemary and Rue is the first book in the October Daye series by Seanan McGuire.
October "Toby" Daye is a private investigator who just happens to be half fae, Daoine Sidhe. Her mother, Amandine, is one of the most powerful of the Daoine Sidhe and her father is human. Toby attempts to balance a life and family until one day when a mission goes wrong. While recovering from this mission Toby tries to shun the fae world, only thing is...they don't want to be shunned. Approached by a high ranking member of the fae, Toby is forced back into their world in order to solve a mystery. This mystery takes her down dangerous roads filled with friends and enemies.
This is a wonderful start for a very interesting series, I found the main character very real and look forward to seeing her development over the series. I will say that the series is filed with what seems is a large amount of characters, however I found that once I figured out who everyone was the characters worked well together. One thing I really liked was that I was surprised at the ending, I did not see/predict who the "bad person" was.
October "Toby" Daye is a private investigator who just happens to be half fae, Daoine Sidhe. Her mother, Amandine, is one of the most powerful of the Daoine Sidhe and her father is human. Toby attempts to balance a life and family until one day when a mission goes wrong. While recovering from this mission Toby tries to shun the fae world, only thing is...they don't want to be shunned. Approached by a high ranking member of the fae, Toby is forced back into their world in order to solve a mystery. This mystery takes her down dangerous roads filled with friends and enemies.
This is a wonderful start for a very interesting series, I found the main character very real and look forward to seeing her development over the series. I will say that the series is filed with what seems is a large amount of characters, however I found that once I figured out who everyone was the characters worked well together. One thing I really liked was that I was surprised at the ending, I did not see/predict who the "bad person" was.
#1 October "Toby" Daye paranormal. October is half-human, half fae changeling, who has just come out of the pond--having been cursed, she spent 14 years as a fish in a koi pond in a public park in San Francisco. During that time, she lost everything--her boyfriend, her daughter--who was four when she 'disappeared' and now wants nothing to do with her--her private eye business, and she remembers very little of her time underwater.
Only the fae world, which time affects differently, still know who she is, although she is trying to make it in the human world. Working nights in a supermarket and living hand-to-mouth in a crummy apartment, October's life suddenly changes forever--again--when she is charged by a dying fae sometime friend to find her killer--and it's a request that Toby can neither refuse nor ignore--it is tied to a curse that will see her dead if she doesn't fulfill the directive. Trying to navigate fae politics and current feuds and alliances, she finds that much has changed even in the short (by fae standards) time she was gone.
I enjoyed this quite a lot, although there were a lot of different characters and 'types' of fae to try to keep straight, and the subplots were perhaps a bit complicated for an introductory book. The few main characters were very interesting and well-fleshed though--Toby especially--and I'm definitely planning to read on.
Only the fae world, which time affects differently, still know who she is, although she is trying to make it in the human world. Working nights in a supermarket and living hand-to-mouth in a crummy apartment, October's life suddenly changes forever--again--when she is charged by a dying fae sometime friend to find her killer--and it's a request that Toby can neither refuse nor ignore--it is tied to a curse that will see her dead if she doesn't fulfill the directive. Trying to navigate fae politics and current feuds and alliances, she finds that much has changed even in the short (by fae standards) time she was gone.
I enjoyed this quite a lot, although there were a lot of different characters and 'types' of fae to try to keep straight, and the subplots were perhaps a bit complicated for an introductory book. The few main characters were very interesting and well-fleshed though--Toby especially--and I'm definitely planning to read on.
Rosemary and Rue follows a Changeling, Toby, through her many disastrous adventures. First you wonder how she made this far in life, and why she would have chosen to be a P.I. in the first place. The book was okay. It was a "who done it" and I had that figured out half way in, but Toby is pretty likable and along the way there are a few more characters that grow on you. Overall the book was pretty good and as a series it may get better.
Stephanie C W. (stephanie13w) reviewed Rosemary and Rue (October Daye, Bk 1) on + 300 more book reviews
This was a great book ~ I liked the characters, flaws & all. A good start to a new series.
Enjoyed the story and characters. Have put the second book on my wishlist
It didn't take me very long to fall in love with the world building in this book. I could see San Francisco and I could see the hidden parts and faerie creatures that were everywhere for Toby, but hidden from human eyes. Some parts are beautiful, some are scary and gritty, and there are so many varieties of creatures from Pixies and Undine to Cait Sidhe to Kitsune. And then we have the halfbreeds and the changelings, like Toby, who are considered lower caste for their human blood, diluted magic, and shorter lives. In Toby's opinion, changelings have the short end of the stick, because no one knows what to do with them really, they don't belong in the human world, but they aren't treated well by the faerie.
There are quite a few characters we're introduced to throughout the book. Toby has a lot of friends, many with back stories hinted at throughout the book. I liked a lot of them and wanted to read more. Hopefully many of them will be reoccurring characters in this series. There's also suggestions of possible romantic interest in Toby, but only very brief ones, this is still an urban fantasy. Two of these guys I firmly believed to be *wrong* for her and I was rooting against them. I already had my favorite ship, which I share with Ana of the Book Smugglers - Tybalt, the king of the Cait Sidhe.
The prologue gives you a pretty good indication of the author's storytelling - things get messy for our heroine. This book has some gritty aspects along with the prettiness: deaths, kids being exploited, unhappy people. Toby makes mistakes and the bad guys are willing to do anything to get what they want. This means Toby gets very beaten up in this book while trying to figure out who killed her friend. I liked that Toby finds out some harsh truths about herself, but the constant rebounding Toby has to do to get there was exhausting. But overall: I'd say it made me excited to read this.
There are quite a few characters we're introduced to throughout the book. Toby has a lot of friends, many with back stories hinted at throughout the book. I liked a lot of them and wanted to read more. Hopefully many of them will be reoccurring characters in this series. There's also suggestions of possible romantic interest in Toby, but only very brief ones, this is still an urban fantasy. Two of these guys I firmly believed to be *wrong* for her and I was rooting against them. I already had my favorite ship, which I share with Ana of the Book Smugglers - Tybalt, the king of the Cait Sidhe.
The prologue gives you a pretty good indication of the author's storytelling - things get messy for our heroine. This book has some gritty aspects along with the prettiness: deaths, kids being exploited, unhappy people. Toby makes mistakes and the bad guys are willing to do anything to get what they want. This means Toby gets very beaten up in this book while trying to figure out who killed her friend. I liked that Toby finds out some harsh truths about herself, but the constant rebounding Toby has to do to get there was exhausting. But overall: I'd say it made me excited to read this.
After reading many of her later novels, this one was obviously early in her career, but it starts off one of my favorite series. I do recommend reading it, if only to appreciate the author's growth with later work.
Danielle R. (danielleraybuck) reviewed Rosemary and Rue (October Daye, Bk 1) on + 76 more book reviews
Not bad. Very complex with a shocking ending. I was surprised.
Kimberly N. (kimberlyrav) -
Too much description, not enough action or conversation. I became very bored. Stopped half way. I spent the time reading it and I dang well have a right to rate it.
