Cheryl R. (Spuddie) -
Helpful Score: 1
#4 Armand Gamache "Three Pines" mystery set in Quebec. Gamache and his wife of thirty-five years are staying at a secluded, exclusive resort in the forest, where they've spent each of their wedding anniversaries. Normally it's a time of relaxation and luxury for them, but this time they end up sharing the resort with the wealthy and snooty Finney family, who are holding their yearly family reunion a bit early. Gamache and his wife are surprised to learn that the youngest son, who arrives a day or two late, is their friend Peter Morrow from Three Pines.
Trouble is brewing within the strained confines of the family, and when Julia Martin, Peter's sister, is murdered--found crushed under a newly-erected statue of their father, Charlies Morrow--Gamache must consider his friend (and Peter's wife Clara as well) a suspect along with everyone else in the family. Gamache moves his crack homicide team in, and they begin digging into the lives of all the cruel and eccentric Finney/Morrows family members, as well as the resort staff.
I love this series more with each book I read. The whole package--the author's writing style, the wonderful characterizations, the whole Quebecois culture, and the mystery itself, which I didn't figure out til the reveal. I did recognize important clues when they came up for the most part, but my brain just couldn't put them all together to solve it. Very clever! I much look forward to the next in series, which I have here and was relieved to see another forthcoming after that. This series ranks among my current top ten favorites. VERY near the top!
Trouble is brewing within the strained confines of the family, and when Julia Martin, Peter's sister, is murdered--found crushed under a newly-erected statue of their father, Charlies Morrow--Gamache must consider his friend (and Peter's wife Clara as well) a suspect along with everyone else in the family. Gamache moves his crack homicide team in, and they begin digging into the lives of all the cruel and eccentric Finney/Morrows family members, as well as the resort staff.
I love this series more with each book I read. The whole package--the author's writing style, the wonderful characterizations, the whole Quebecois culture, and the mystery itself, which I didn't figure out til the reveal. I did recognize important clues when they came up for the most part, but my brain just couldn't put them all together to solve it. Very clever! I much look forward to the next in series, which I have here and was relieved to see another forthcoming after that. This series ranks among my current top ten favorites. VERY near the top!
Joanne C. reviewed A Rule Against Murder (aka The Murder Stone) (Chief Inspector Gamache, Bk 4) on + 8 more book reviews
Helpful Score: 1
I enjoy these mild mysteries set in Quebec Province. The characters are interesting and there is not a lot of graphic violence.
Cathy C. (cathyskye) -
Helpful Score: 1
First Line: "In the height of summer the guests descended on the isolated lodge by the lake, summoned to the Manoir Bellechasse by identical vellum invitations, addressed in the familiar spider scrawl as though written in cobwebs."
For once the action in this fourth book in Penny's excellent series takes place outside the charming village of Three Pines, thus dodging the "Cabot Cove" bullet.
Inspector Armand Gamache and his wife Reine-Marie are at the isolated Manoir Bellechasse to celebrate their wedding anniversary. Unfortunately the lodge is overrun by the wealthy, entitled and whiny Morrow clan, but the pair are able to shut the Morrows out and enjoy themselves. The obnoxious clan dismisses the pair as "a shopkeeper and his cleaning woman wife", and that's fine with Gamache and Reine-Marie.
In exchange for agreeing to take over some of the operating costs, the Morrows erect a statue of the deceased head of the clan on the grounds of Bellechasse. After a furious late night thunderstorm, one of the gardeners discovers the body of Julia Morrow beneath the toppled statue. How on earth was someone able to knock over the statue without leaving a scratch on its base, and who wanted to kill Julia Morrow...and why?
Gamache bundles Reine-Marie off to Three Pines to keep her out of harm's way as he calls in his staff and begins to investigate. The shock when the Morrows discover the inspector's true identity is quite pleasurable. What isn't pleasurable is the discovery that Peter and Clara of Three Pines are members of the Morrow clan. No wonder they've kept that fact hidden, for this clan was tailor made for Gamache to investigate:
'And Gamache? He knew he was neither the hound nor the hunter. Armand Gamache was the explorer. He went ahead of all the rest, into territory unknown and uncharted. He was drawn to the edge of things. To the places old mariners knew, and warned, "Beyond here be monsters."'
One of the delights of reading A Rule Against Murder was learning more of Gamache's background, of discovering what happened in his youth to make him the rather strange and very understanding man that he is in these books. What isn't so delightful is learning about the odious Morrow clan, one of whose members named her child Bean and hasn't told anyone Bean's sex-- and no Morrow has even asked!
"Are you kidding? A Morrow ask a question? Admit ignorance?" She leaned forward conspiratorially and despite himself Beauvoir leaned forward to meet her. "That's the brilliance of this. Their own ignorance is my best weapon."
That's quite a crew, isn't it?
The more I read, the more I sank into the characterizations. They reign supreme in this book. I sank so far that I totally forgot to gather clues and when the identity of the murderer was revealed, I was shocked. The explanation for moving the statue almost made me smack my forehead. Penny had neatly planted clues from the very beginning as to the killer's identity and methods, but I was oblivious to them all.
That's the power of Louise Penny. She's created an entire world, her own version of Shangri-La, and peopled it with so many fascinating characters that it's all too easy to forget that you're reading a mystery and supposed to be gathering together the pieces of the puzzle. For me, A Rule Against Murder is the strongest book in the series so far, and I look forward to the next, The Brutal Telling, with a great deal of anticipation.
For once the action in this fourth book in Penny's excellent series takes place outside the charming village of Three Pines, thus dodging the "Cabot Cove" bullet.
Inspector Armand Gamache and his wife Reine-Marie are at the isolated Manoir Bellechasse to celebrate their wedding anniversary. Unfortunately the lodge is overrun by the wealthy, entitled and whiny Morrow clan, but the pair are able to shut the Morrows out and enjoy themselves. The obnoxious clan dismisses the pair as "a shopkeeper and his cleaning woman wife", and that's fine with Gamache and Reine-Marie.
In exchange for agreeing to take over some of the operating costs, the Morrows erect a statue of the deceased head of the clan on the grounds of Bellechasse. After a furious late night thunderstorm, one of the gardeners discovers the body of Julia Morrow beneath the toppled statue. How on earth was someone able to knock over the statue without leaving a scratch on its base, and who wanted to kill Julia Morrow...and why?
Gamache bundles Reine-Marie off to Three Pines to keep her out of harm's way as he calls in his staff and begins to investigate. The shock when the Morrows discover the inspector's true identity is quite pleasurable. What isn't pleasurable is the discovery that Peter and Clara of Three Pines are members of the Morrow clan. No wonder they've kept that fact hidden, for this clan was tailor made for Gamache to investigate:
'And Gamache? He knew he was neither the hound nor the hunter. Armand Gamache was the explorer. He went ahead of all the rest, into territory unknown and uncharted. He was drawn to the edge of things. To the places old mariners knew, and warned, "Beyond here be monsters."'
One of the delights of reading A Rule Against Murder was learning more of Gamache's background, of discovering what happened in his youth to make him the rather strange and very understanding man that he is in these books. What isn't so delightful is learning about the odious Morrow clan, one of whose members named her child Bean and hasn't told anyone Bean's sex-- and no Morrow has even asked!
"Are you kidding? A Morrow ask a question? Admit ignorance?" She leaned forward conspiratorially and despite himself Beauvoir leaned forward to meet her. "That's the brilliance of this. Their own ignorance is my best weapon."
That's quite a crew, isn't it?
The more I read, the more I sank into the characterizations. They reign supreme in this book. I sank so far that I totally forgot to gather clues and when the identity of the murderer was revealed, I was shocked. The explanation for moving the statue almost made me smack my forehead. Penny had neatly planted clues from the very beginning as to the killer's identity and methods, but I was oblivious to them all.
That's the power of Louise Penny. She's created an entire world, her own version of Shangri-La, and peopled it with so many fascinating characters that it's all too easy to forget that you're reading a mystery and supposed to be gathering together the pieces of the puzzle. For me, A Rule Against Murder is the strongest book in the series so far, and I look forward to the next, The Brutal Telling, with a great deal of anticipation.
Linda T. (dulcilinda) - , reviewed A Rule Against Murder (aka The Murder Stone) (Chief Inspector Gamache, Bk 4) on + 6 more book reviews
I've been reading good and not-so-good books for a long time, now.
I read, mostly, lots of highly-regarded current fiction and murder mysteries.
This is both.
Themes of universal meaning are examined.
Many central characters are explored in depth, one by one, throughout the series.
This is #4.
#s 5 and 6 have already been published and I've read #5 (The Brutal Telling.)
Plus, you're likely to be surprised at the plot twists.
It's every bit as good as A Rule Against Murder, also known as The Murder Stone.
I highly recommend this entire series.
Excellent stuff.
I read, mostly, lots of highly-regarded current fiction and murder mysteries.
This is both.
Themes of universal meaning are examined.
Many central characters are explored in depth, one by one, throughout the series.
This is #4.
#s 5 and 6 have already been published and I've read #5 (The Brutal Telling.)
Plus, you're likely to be surprised at the plot twists.
It's every bit as good as A Rule Against Murder, also known as The Murder Stone.
I highly recommend this entire series.
Excellent stuff.
Virginia S. reviewed A Rule Against Murder (aka The Murder Stone) (Chief Inspector Gamache, Bk 4) on + 3 more book reviews
Another able installment in Penny's Chief Inspector Gamache series. These books make great light reading, with well-paced plotting and characters you'd like to know. The best "character" by far is the setting--the charming, quirky, friendly village of Three Pines. I want to go to there.
Judith L. (jlautner) reviewed A Rule Against Murder (aka The Murder Stone) (Chief Inspector Gamache, Bk 4) on + 105 more book reviews
Fourth in the Armand Gamache series. Gamache and wife Reine-Marie are celebrating their anniversary at a remote hotel, Manoir Bellechasse. They have been coming to this hotel for many years and are happy to take any room. This time they are joined by the Finney clan, who take up all of the remaining rooms. It is a reunion of sorts, in this case to honor the passing of the patriarch of the family. It is clear to Gamache from the start that these family members have issues.
A big part of the memorial to the father is the installation of a huge statue of the man in the garden. The small hotel is happy to accept this addition given how generous the family has been to the hotel. The statue is revealed in a ceremony but the next day daughter Jules is found dead, crushed by the statue. It had somehow come off its base.
It isn't long before Gamache has undertaken the case and brought in his team as well as local police to help. An unexpected help comes from Clara, artist friend from the village of Three Pines, who is married to Peter, one of the Finneys. The couple is there reluctantly as is the case for most of the other siblings.
It was not an accident. But how it was done is a mystery to Gamache. In interviews with the family members and hotel staff, he finds many possible motives, unfortunately.
I enjoyed getting to know Gamache a bit more with this case, and to learn more about Clara as well. Clara seems to be the main character in Three Pines, the one we really get to know. Their mutual friendship seems to be based on compassion and love of beauty.
A big part of the memorial to the father is the installation of a huge statue of the man in the garden. The small hotel is happy to accept this addition given how generous the family has been to the hotel. The statue is revealed in a ceremony but the next day daughter Jules is found dead, crushed by the statue. It had somehow come off its base.
It isn't long before Gamache has undertaken the case and brought in his team as well as local police to help. An unexpected help comes from Clara, artist friend from the village of Three Pines, who is married to Peter, one of the Finneys. The couple is there reluctantly as is the case for most of the other siblings.
It was not an accident. But how it was done is a mystery to Gamache. In interviews with the family members and hotel staff, he finds many possible motives, unfortunately.
I enjoyed getting to know Gamache a bit more with this case, and to learn more about Clara as well. Clara seems to be the main character in Three Pines, the one we really get to know. Their mutual friendship seems to be based on compassion and love of beauty.
Cheryl E. (Cheryl74) reviewed A Rule Against Murder (aka The Murder Stone) (Chief Inspector Gamache, Bk 4) on + 40 more book reviews
I have read all of the books in order, except the last one, which I will read next. I really liked books 1-3, but this one not as much. I think one of the reasons is because most of the story does not take place in Three Pines. However, Three Pines is a VERY small and cozy town and I'm beginning to wonder how many murders could take place there before all of the citizens decide to move. I also feel that maybe there is a deeper meaning to these books that is going over my head. I still don't understand why Bean used so many alarm clocks. Also, why does the chef feel the need to hide away from the real world? Could someone please enlighten me?
Cindy R. - , reviewed A Rule Against Murder (aka The Murder Stone) (Chief Inspector Gamache, Bk 4) on + 3 more book reviews
It was a good mystery set in the wilds of Canada with a French detecive and very interesting guests at a remote lodge. I enjoyed it.
Karen S. (MKSbooklady) reviewed A Rule Against Murder (aka The Murder Stone) (Chief Inspector Gamache, Bk 4) on + 989 more book reviews
Another 'Three Pines' Mystery, but most of it takes place out of the tiny village. Inspector Gamache is the central character again, and his wife has a more prominent role than in previous books.
The Three Pines books are always easy to ready, part murder mystery, part psychological drama-this is the 4th I have read of the series, and will read more.
The Three Pines books are always easy to ready, part murder mystery, part psychological drama-this is the 4th I have read of the series, and will read more.
Judy E. (ebeybooks) reviewed A Rule Against Murder (aka The Murder Stone) (Chief Inspector Gamache, Bk 4) on
I enjoy reading mysteries, especially those set in places I am not familiar with. Louise Penny and the Canadian Wilderness of the Quebec Province kept me turning pages. I enjoy the Inspector Gamache mysteries in general and this 4th one in particular. The characters are interesting, the scenery is beautiful, the blood and gore is minimal, and I was kept in the dark about the WHO and the WHY until the very end. My one complaint is the unnecessary use of the "F-word" by generally educated, relatively sophisticated characters in the book. It seemed to serve no purpose â except to distract and irritate me!
Frank H. (perryfran) reviewed A Rule Against Murder (aka The Murder Stone) (Chief Inspector Gamache, Bk 4) on + 1223 more book reviews
This one was a little bit of a departure from the first three novels in the series in that most of the book takes place in the Manoir Bellechasse, an isolated lodge by a lake in Quebec, rather than in the quaint town of Three Pines. I have been slowly making my way through this series after seeing a piece about Louise Penny on the CBS Morning TV show several months ago.
Inspector Gamache and his wife are celebrating their anniversary at the lodge and as it turns out, a very dysfunctional family, the Finneys, are also there for a family reunion. The family is expecting one other brother to come to the reunion nicknamed Spot. Well it turns out that Spot is actually Peter Morrow, the artist from Three Pines. He shows up with his wife Clara into a very uncomfortable atmosphere of the very strange family who are actually the Morrows (Peter's mother remarried a Finney). Anyway, it's not long before a murder of one of the Morrow sisters (Julia) happens in a most unusual manner...a statue of the elder Morrow, Peter's father, falls and crushes her. So Gamache is back in his element trying to solve the crime. The how it was committed is the hardest because he and his crew are perplexed as to how anyone could topple the heavy statue. But in the end it becomes clear as Gamache wades through the clues.
Overall, I enjoyed this one but maybe not quite as much as the previous entries in the series. The Morrow family is so bizarre and hateful towards each other that it seems far-fetched that the family would do yearly reunions. One of the strangest is the youngest sister, Marianna, who has a child named Bean. Marianna has kept the sex of Bean a secret and no one knows whether Bean is a boy or girl. Peter also comes off as rather obnoxious especially when he was younger and full of jealousies towards his siblings. He also still seems jealous of Clara's art and her upcoming showing. Also, the eventual solution to the crime was kind of unsatisfying with the motivations seeming a little contrived.
Inspector Gamache and his wife are celebrating their anniversary at the lodge and as it turns out, a very dysfunctional family, the Finneys, are also there for a family reunion. The family is expecting one other brother to come to the reunion nicknamed Spot. Well it turns out that Spot is actually Peter Morrow, the artist from Three Pines. He shows up with his wife Clara into a very uncomfortable atmosphere of the very strange family who are actually the Morrows (Peter's mother remarried a Finney). Anyway, it's not long before a murder of one of the Morrow sisters (Julia) happens in a most unusual manner...a statue of the elder Morrow, Peter's father, falls and crushes her. So Gamache is back in his element trying to solve the crime. The how it was committed is the hardest because he and his crew are perplexed as to how anyone could topple the heavy statue. But in the end it becomes clear as Gamache wades through the clues.
Overall, I enjoyed this one but maybe not quite as much as the previous entries in the series. The Morrow family is so bizarre and hateful towards each other that it seems far-fetched that the family would do yearly reunions. One of the strangest is the youngest sister, Marianna, who has a child named Bean. Marianna has kept the sex of Bean a secret and no one knows whether Bean is a boy or girl. Peter also comes off as rather obnoxious especially when he was younger and full of jealousies towards his siblings. He also still seems jealous of Clara's art and her upcoming showing. Also, the eventual solution to the crime was kind of unsatisfying with the motivations seeming a little contrived.
Barbara M. reviewed A Rule Against Murder (aka The Murder Stone) (Chief Inspector Gamache, Bk 4) on + 152 more book reviews
Although I've read mysteries for years, I had never heard of Louise Penny until she was featured on a CBS Sunday Morning program segment about three years ago. So, I decided to read her series in order. She's a descriptive writer and her books are fairly easy reads. The scenario in this book is a little improbable--the central character (Chief Inspector Armand Gamache) and his wife celebrate each anniversary at a particular lodge out in the boonies, and this story takes place while they are at the lodge. A dysfunctional family (the Morrows), consisting of matriarch and her second husband, four adult children, and one grand child, are having a reunion also during this time. Interestingly, one of the adult sons and his wife are acquaintances of the Gamaches. It's a little too convenient that the reunion--where someone is killed--occurs at the same time the Gamaches are at the lodge.
I was surprised at who the murderer was, and the motive seemed weak. Also, it was never explained (at least that I can recall--and I recently read the book) how the murderer lured the victim to the crime scene.
The Morrow matriach is an unpleasant woman who cannot seem to find anything nice to say about anyone, including her own children. POSSIBLE SPOILERS: At the end, we learn she has neuralgia and it's painful for her to touch or be touched, which is the reason she's never shown physical affection to her children (who are unaware of her condition). That's understandable but it doesn't explain why she has such a nasty disposition. Peter, one of the adult children and the person who knows Gamache, turns out to be a weak, self-serving individual and just as nasty as the rest of the family. Hopefully, he'll be killed off or written out of the series at some point. As I was nearing the end of the book, I wondered if the sex of Bean, the nine-year old Morrow grand child, would be revealed. It wasn't.
I was surprised at who the murderer was, and the motive seemed weak. Also, it was never explained (at least that I can recall--and I recently read the book) how the murderer lured the victim to the crime scene.
The Morrow matriach is an unpleasant woman who cannot seem to find anything nice to say about anyone, including her own children. POSSIBLE SPOILERS: At the end, we learn she has neuralgia and it's painful for her to touch or be touched, which is the reason she's never shown physical affection to her children (who are unaware of her condition). That's understandable but it doesn't explain why she has such a nasty disposition. Peter, one of the adult children and the person who knows Gamache, turns out to be a weak, self-serving individual and just as nasty as the rest of the family. Hopefully, he'll be killed off or written out of the series at some point. As I was nearing the end of the book, I wondered if the sex of Bean, the nine-year old Morrow grand child, would be revealed. It wasn't.
