Susan M. (susyclemens) reviewed Silent Melody (Kendrick & Marlowe Siblings, Bk 2) on + 158 more book reviews
Helpful Score: 2
Very disappointed in this. It has all of Mary Balogh's worst traits as an author. The heroine is very passive; the hero is emotionally confused and a real "taker" rather than a giver. For example, he
SPOILER ALERT:
---------
takes the heroine's virginity and belatedly offers to marry her, but, she wants a kind of independence, and also isn't sure he could ever *love* her... the lame-est sort of delay between a hero/heroine's eventual HEA that an author can put in a romance.
---------- END OF SPOILER
There's a creepy subtext later on in the story, where a criminally sick man preys on the hero and heroine (especially the heroine). Bleh. I don't understand the raves for this story. I found it a little disturbing, and a lot just plain boring.
SPOILER ALERT:
---------
takes the heroine's virginity and belatedly offers to marry her, but, she wants a kind of independence, and also isn't sure he could ever *love* her... the lame-est sort of delay between a hero/heroine's eventual HEA that an author can put in a romance.
---------- END OF SPOILER
There's a creepy subtext later on in the story, where a criminally sick man preys on the hero and heroine (especially the heroine). Bleh. I don't understand the raves for this story. I found it a little disturbing, and a lot just plain boring.
Maria P. (BklynMom) - , reviewed Silent Melody (Kendrick & Marlowe Siblings, Bk 2) on + 541 more book reviews
Helpful Score: 2
The story of Lady Emily, a deaf-mute loved and protected by her family and her childhood soul mate, Ashley. He is tortured by guilt and a nasty suspicion and returns to England after a 7 year hiatus.. She is a breath away from being betrothed and then all kinds of emotions come up. Altho I love Balogh, this one took a long time to get to the point.
"For readers who really want both history and romance in their historical romances."
Janet R. (taryndesigns) -
I really liked the characters in this book and the plot was a little more unusual then most of her books. For some reason though, I found some of the speech a little annoying.
Sheryl R. (phydeaux) -
Great story that I've re-read a few times. The heroine cannot hear or speak.
Enjoyed Silent Melody very much.
Simone W. (mamawaite) reviewed Silent Melody (Kendrick & Marlowe Siblings, Bk 2) on + 175 more book reviews
Loved this book! Vintage Mary Balogh. The hero so brave and the heroine even mor brave. A great read.
Eleanor G. (Memom) - , reviewed Silent Melody (Kendrick & Marlowe Siblings, Bk 2) on + 441 more book reviews
Lovely Lovely story.
