Helpful Score: 1
If you like Deborah Crombie, you will probably enjoy Where Memories Lie. I'm not sure it is one of her more intriguing efforts, and I am not fond of narratives that move between the past (WWII) and the present, but Gemma and Duncan are working a case together again, and along with the quotidian aspects of their daily life, there are a series of murders in the present to solve that are rooted in the past. I think perhaps Crombie got so caught up in the historical aspects of the story, she neglected the actual mystery, but the characters are interesting, even if many of them are not as sharply drawn as they could be, and the ending in possibly not what you would expect. I enjoy Crombie's writing and her characterizations. This is not the most compelling mystery, nor story, however.
Cathy C. (cathyskye) -
Helpful Score: 1
First Line: The day was utterly miserable for early May, even considering the expected vagaries of English weather.
When a diamond brooch, stolen decades ago, turns up for sale in a London auction house, the owner, Dr. Erika Rosenthal, turns to her friend Inspector Gemma James for help. Rosenthal and her husband escaped Nazi Germany, and the brooch was stolen on their journey to England. Gemma barely begins to investigate when a young auction house employee connected to the sale of the brooch is killed. Soon anyone who had anything to do with the brooch seems to meet a fatal accident.
Woven in with this mystery is the unsolved murder of Rosenthal's husband in 1952, but in many ways, this book has more to do with the personal lives of the characters than the mystery... at least it felt that way to me. This is not a complaint because Crombie's characters are some of my absolute favorites, and their lives are just as important to me as the mysteries they solve. Fortunately Crombie is quite skilled at providing intriguing mysteries while advancing the lives of her characters.
Although I deduced the killer about halfway through the book, if I'd twigged to one small clue, it would have been much earlier. Once learned that one small clue seemed so obvious that I feel I should turn in my Junior G-Man badge in shame.
If I ever have any sort of reading slump, I've become accustomed to turning to Crombie to get me back on the rails. Unfortunately I have only one book left in the series before I'm all caught up and forced to wait for the newest one. You may not be able to tell from there, but I'm sitting here pouting.
When a diamond brooch, stolen decades ago, turns up for sale in a London auction house, the owner, Dr. Erika Rosenthal, turns to her friend Inspector Gemma James for help. Rosenthal and her husband escaped Nazi Germany, and the brooch was stolen on their journey to England. Gemma barely begins to investigate when a young auction house employee connected to the sale of the brooch is killed. Soon anyone who had anything to do with the brooch seems to meet a fatal accident.
Woven in with this mystery is the unsolved murder of Rosenthal's husband in 1952, but in many ways, this book has more to do with the personal lives of the characters than the mystery... at least it felt that way to me. This is not a complaint because Crombie's characters are some of my absolute favorites, and their lives are just as important to me as the mysteries they solve. Fortunately Crombie is quite skilled at providing intriguing mysteries while advancing the lives of her characters.
Although I deduced the killer about halfway through the book, if I'd twigged to one small clue, it would have been much earlier. Once learned that one small clue seemed so obvious that I feel I should turn in my Junior G-Man badge in shame.
If I ever have any sort of reading slump, I've become accustomed to turning to Crombie to get me back on the rails. Unfortunately I have only one book left in the series before I'm all caught up and forced to wait for the newest one. You may not be able to tell from there, but I'm sitting here pouting.
Etherege reviewed Where Memories Lie (Duncan Kincaid / Gemma James, Bk 12) on + 10 more book reviews
One of her best. Fascinating interplay of two different times, two different murders. Great characters; denouement perhaps rather far-fetched, but an excellent story nonetheless.
Duncan and Gemma deliver again. This series is absolutely addictive. You want to start at the beginning of the relationship and go through all it's ups and downs. You quickly learn to love the characters, who are believable and very human.
