Cathy C. (cathyskye) -
When I read this emotionally charged book and learned that at the time of the Civil War Jacksonville, Illinois had been known as "the Athens of the West," I almost choked. I grew up not far from Jacksonville, and I knew it as the home of "the state nuthouse." But that's just geography. When I learned of this book, I knew that it would resonate with me and not just because I'm a woman and well aware of how my gender has been treated by the opposite sex. My mother had what was then termed a nervous breakdown when I was an infant, and she underwent electroshock therapy to snap her out of it. Living with Mom made me very aware of the stigma that is applied to anyone with the slightest hint of mental illness about them. As a teenager, I did volunteer work at a mental health center that had a program bringing patients from the hospital in Jacksonville to the center to be rehabilitated.
So... I'm familiar with the area, and I'm a woman with more than a passing acquaintance with mental illness. I'm also a reader aware of the abominable way mentally ill people have been treated down through the centuries. No wonder I expected to be horrified and angered by reading The Woman They Could Not Silence. Was I? You bet!
But much more than that, I was uplifted by Elizabeth Packard. What a marvelous human being! It was an emotional experience to watch this woman's character be forged through her time in the mental hospital. At first, she was a woman of her time. Her husband had falsely accused and forsaken her, so she looked to another man to rescue her. The man she turned to was Dr. Andrew McFarland. However, her thinking was flawed. McFarland was even more dangerous than her husband. Time after time, I found Elizabeth's naïveté heartbreaking, but once she realized that she could count on no one but herself to obtain her freedom, there was no stopping her. Wow!
Elizabeth Packard almost single-handedly changed the laws in many states pertaining to married women's rights to their own wages and property as well as to the commitment and treatment of the mentally ill. Think crowdfunding is a 21st-century resource? Think again. Elizabeth Packard was an expert practitioner. This woman had flaws, but she also had so much empathy, compassion, intelligence, determination... She should have been a shining example to us all for over one hundred fifty years, but instead, she was consigned to obscurity, a centenary in the Jacksonville papers labeling her "a minor league nut" who "couldn't keep her mouth shut."
As Kate Moore says in her Author's Note: "So in the end, this a book about power. Who wields it. Who owns it. And the methods they use. And above all, it's about fighting back." I, for one, am grateful that Moore brought Elizabeth Packard back into the light. More than ever, this world needs to follow the examples set by such beacons of humanity.
So... I'm familiar with the area, and I'm a woman with more than a passing acquaintance with mental illness. I'm also a reader aware of the abominable way mentally ill people have been treated down through the centuries. No wonder I expected to be horrified and angered by reading The Woman They Could Not Silence. Was I? You bet!
But much more than that, I was uplifted by Elizabeth Packard. What a marvelous human being! It was an emotional experience to watch this woman's character be forged through her time in the mental hospital. At first, she was a woman of her time. Her husband had falsely accused and forsaken her, so she looked to another man to rescue her. The man she turned to was Dr. Andrew McFarland. However, her thinking was flawed. McFarland was even more dangerous than her husband. Time after time, I found Elizabeth's naïveté heartbreaking, but once she realized that she could count on no one but herself to obtain her freedom, there was no stopping her. Wow!
Elizabeth Packard almost single-handedly changed the laws in many states pertaining to married women's rights to their own wages and property as well as to the commitment and treatment of the mentally ill. Think crowdfunding is a 21st-century resource? Think again. Elizabeth Packard was an expert practitioner. This woman had flaws, but she also had so much empathy, compassion, intelligence, determination... She should have been a shining example to us all for over one hundred fifty years, but instead, she was consigned to obscurity, a centenary in the Jacksonville papers labeling her "a minor league nut" who "couldn't keep her mouth shut."
As Kate Moore says in her Author's Note: "So in the end, this a book about power. Who wields it. Who owns it. And the methods they use. And above all, it's about fighting back." I, for one, am grateful that Moore brought Elizabeth Packard back into the light. More than ever, this world needs to follow the examples set by such beacons of humanity.
Eadie B. (eadieburke) -
1860. This is a true story of the historical battle for women's mental health rights. Elizabeth Packard's husband of twenty-one years feels increasingly threatened by Elizabeth's intellect, independence, and unwillingness to stifle her own thoughts. He makes plans to put his wife back in her place by committing her to an insane asylum. There are many rational women on her ward who have been committed in order to keep them in line. Elizabeth's refusal to be silenced and her ceaseless quest for justice challenged the medical science of the day, and led to a giant leap forward in women's human rights. I enjoyed this book but thought it could be shorter as it repeated facts too many times. If you enjoy stories about forgotten women of history, then you will enjoy this book.
