I picked up this book because Id seen it mentioned as a swashbuckling sea adventure with plenty of action and piracy.
However, reading it, I was reminded that when I was a kid I went through a big phase of reading lots of historical nautical books, both fiction and non-fiction. (There were lots of sailors and sea voyages in my family history, which is where the interest stemmed from check out THIS BOOK, it features my distant relative getting cannibalized) So, although I dont know HOW to sail or anything like that, I feel that Ive got a pretty good concept of what life was like on a 19th-century sailing ship. And, in this book, I just wasnt feeling it. I didnt notice many inaccuracies (other than that I found it hard to believe that on a ship of 26 hands, there would be sailors that didnt know each other after any amount of voyaging) but I just wanted more details of shipboard life but, this is a book that doesnt get bogged down in details or verisimilitude it actually, I think, would make a very good movie and Im sure that must have been in Gene Hackmans mind when he was working on it. Its got just about the level of depth and characterization of your average big-budget movie, with plenty of action scenes, local color and exotic locations (all politically-corrected, to a certain degree.)
The story has to do with a young man who takes to the sea after his parents are murdered by a Cuban Count who seizes the family property. He makes friends with another young man, a victim of shipwreck, and together they have seagoing adventures, as he waits for his chance to take revenge The checklist of Things That Happen At Sea occurs, fairly predictably the standout scenes are diving scenes, which (considering that Lenihan is a deep-sea diving expert) seem technically very believable, if contextually very unlikely.
However, reading it, I was reminded that when I was a kid I went through a big phase of reading lots of historical nautical books, both fiction and non-fiction. (There were lots of sailors and sea voyages in my family history, which is where the interest stemmed from check out THIS BOOK, it features my distant relative getting cannibalized) So, although I dont know HOW to sail or anything like that, I feel that Ive got a pretty good concept of what life was like on a 19th-century sailing ship. And, in this book, I just wasnt feeling it. I didnt notice many inaccuracies (other than that I found it hard to believe that on a ship of 26 hands, there would be sailors that didnt know each other after any amount of voyaging) but I just wanted more details of shipboard life but, this is a book that doesnt get bogged down in details or verisimilitude it actually, I think, would make a very good movie and Im sure that must have been in Gene Hackmans mind when he was working on it. Its got just about the level of depth and characterization of your average big-budget movie, with plenty of action scenes, local color and exotic locations (all politically-corrected, to a certain degree.)
The story has to do with a young man who takes to the sea after his parents are murdered by a Cuban Count who seizes the family property. He makes friends with another young man, a victim of shipwreck, and together they have seagoing adventures, as he waits for his chance to take revenge The checklist of Things That Happen At Sea occurs, fairly predictably the standout scenes are diving scenes, which (considering that Lenihan is a deep-sea diving expert) seem technically very believable, if contextually very unlikely.
Back to all reviews by this member
Back to all reviews of this book
Back to Book Reviews
Back to Book Details
Back to all reviews of this book
Back to Book Reviews
Back to Book Details
