Skip to main content
PBS logo
 
 

Book Review of The Talkative Policeman (Inspector Beale, Bk 1)

The Talkative Policeman (Inspector Beale, Bk 1)
WhidbeyIslander avatar reviewed on + 715 more book reviews


This well-named golden age mystery is longer than the usual books of the type. Too long, I thought. Some of the long expositions could have been shortened, or deleted, such as the five pages explaining the science behind fingerprint identification in eye-glazing detail. The dialogue between Beale and his helpers kept me reading since it's snappy and realistic.

As with many of its ilk, there are maps of the area, but I felt one of them was not only a letdown, but misleading (railroad stations are mentioned more than once but the only indication on the map states "R.Station" but shows no tracks, so is that a railroad station? And which one?)

After the 32nd chapter the author challenges the reader to name the killer; those of us who cannot (or do it by guesswork alone) are thought to be "less intelligent." Sort of an arrogant statement. (My guess was wrong, but since I read so slowly, many of the clues were long forgotten by the time I reached chapter 33.)