Debbie E. (debbieae) reviewed on 10/3/2011 + 18 more book reviews

Helpful Score: 2

Well, I have been reading lots of Philippa Gregory over the past year, and have discovered a different Queen Elizabeth than I thought I knew. I am realizing that she got more credit than she was due in revisionist history in her old age and following her death. I am also getting the distinct impression that Philippa Gregory really does not like her at all. Revisionist history or no, could she really be this weak and easilly led by Cecil and be considered anything other than a failure by history?

I think I have really gotten a much better view of many historical figures through her books that give a better idea of who they really are, not just the legend. I find the treatment of Mary Queen of Scots very interesting. Great twist on her relationship with Bothwell that supports the rape allegation while explaining her documented affection and reliance on Bothwell.

It is apparent as little as the author likes Elizabeth, she has a great deal of sympathy for Mary. The Shrewsberrys were a real revelation though. I never gave much thought to Mary's jailers, but their story is fascinating. The Earl sympathetic and enchanted by Mary, the Countess a devotee of the protestant faith and supporter of Cecil more hostile. Their story is probably the best of the bunch.

Back to all reviews by this member
Back to all reviews of this book
Back to Book Reviews
Back to Book Details