Stacie P. (froot) - reviewed on 7/15/2010 + 178 more book reviews

A mere footnote in the world of Twlight. Bree Tanner, a young girl, turned newborn vamp by the evasive and deceptive efforts of Victoria (anti-climatic villian.) Meyer needed this closure more for herself, than for us as readers. Walking a mile in this newborn's shoes is more gooey with plot than necessary. I prefer the simplicity in Eclipse. Bree was perhaps omitted by a skillful editor.

If exploring the world further through the eyes of a newborn was what Meyer wanted to do, then it should have been a stand alone story without the crossover. By the end of this cute little bedtime drama, I felt as if I was reading a deleted scene from Eclipse.

Thank S. Meyer, but next time wash your losses down with a shot of JD. The burn will bring you closer to Bree than this sappy underdeveloped footnote.

Back to all reviews by this member
Back to all reviews of this book
Back to Book Reviews
Back to Book Details