BookMonkey reviewed on 3/11/2010 + 38 more book reviews

Helpful Score: 3

One of the surprise sensations in the publishing industry last year was Quirk Classics' Pride and Prejudice and Zombies, a mashup which re-imagined Elizabeth Bennet as romantically jaded martial arts expert up to her eyes in zombies, also known as 'dreadfuls'. Though railed against by some Jane Austen purists as sacrilege, adding zombies to such a well known, if intimidating, classic arguably exposed it to a new audience of readers who otherwise may well have never read it (in any form). Such success obviously called for a follow up, right?

Naturally. But instead of going the traditional sequel route, Quirk Classics went in the other direction and has given us a prequel: Dawn of the Dreadfuls. Set several years prior to Pride and Prejudice and Zombies, Dawn of the Dreadfuls takes the reader on a journey through the dawn of the zombie plague and Elizabeth's tentative first steps toward becoming the ultimate zombie killing warrior. Along the way we encounter, among other things, a scientific attempt to interact with a dreadful... through music and dancing (just go with it), a creative use of croquet balls and mallets, and the timely arrival of ninjas.

Obviously Jane Austen did not actually write a prequel to Pride and Prejudice, so author Steve Hockensmith had a freer hand than his Pride and Prejudice and Zombies predecessor to create his tale without being tied to source material and he did a great job replicating the feel of Austen's style / presentation. But what made Pride and Prejudice and Zombies a true phenomenon was its creative mashup of classic literate with classic horror, and that hook worked precisely because the reader already knew the story being (lovingly) spoofed. Once the story isn't tied to an actual classic work, well, it's really just another zombie story... in an odd setting.

Don't get me wrong, Dawn of the Dreadfuls is a very entertaining read. It just didn't have quite the same sense of discovery and mischief that was present in Pride and Prejudice and Zombies, that "Look at us poking fun at the 'great work of literature'... by adding zombies!" Of course that could actually work in Dawn of the Dreadfuls favor, as those who were wary of reading classic literature, even with a healthy dose of zombies thrown in, may be more receptive to what is, essentially, a completely original zombie tale.

Back to all reviews by this member
Back to all reviews of this book
Back to Book Reviews
Back to Book Details