Macayla H. (McDigg) reviewed Good story, annoying main character on
I think that if the same storylines as are contained in the "Maisie Dobbs" series involved a different protagonist, I would be praising this series to the skies. As it is, I can only with reservations recommend "Pardonable Lies."
Reading about the aftermath of WWI and how it affected its veterans, nurses and civilians even 12 years after the war ended is very interesting and involving. So much fiction has been written about WWII that WWI has become the red-headed stepchild of world wars and it is commendable that the author helps keep the memories of WWI and its veterans alive. Another integral part of the series is the description of the lives of domestic servants and the class structure that to me as a 21st Century American are so foreign. The mysteries Maisie is hired to solve, particularly in novels nos. 2 and 3, are engrosing and keep you (or at least me) guessing to the end.
The thing that almost ruins these books for me is the character of Maisie. I find myself rolling my eyes very often at the way the author portrays Maisie. She is obviously very much in love with her creation, and so is every other character in the book! So often characters (and the third-person narrator) describe Maisie as "brave" or "special" that it becomes a bit heavy handed. Show us, don't tell us! Maisie comes off to me as a know-it-all egotist and is condescending to her employee, father, servants, and anyone else who she feels doesn't have her level of intelligence. Speaking of intelligence, Maisie seems to have an almost supernatural or psychic ability. I don't know if this is how the author intended to portray the character, but in all three books many connections are made by "a tingling feeling in the back of Maisie's neck" (paraphrasing), and then suddenly Maisie makes this great cognitive leap, or looks up and another clue is found! It is just too ham-fisted to be believable.
So you may ask, why have you read three of the books if you have all these criticisms? Well, honestly, I don't know. I guess in spite of all of my complaints, these are good books. And I live in hope that Maisie will continue on her fascinating adventures but that the author will get over her girl-crush on her own creation and give me a sympathetic character I can root for!
Reading about the aftermath of WWI and how it affected its veterans, nurses and civilians even 12 years after the war ended is very interesting and involving. So much fiction has been written about WWII that WWI has become the red-headed stepchild of world wars and it is commendable that the author helps keep the memories of WWI and its veterans alive. Another integral part of the series is the description of the lives of domestic servants and the class structure that to me as a 21st Century American are so foreign. The mysteries Maisie is hired to solve, particularly in novels nos. 2 and 3, are engrosing and keep you (or at least me) guessing to the end.
The thing that almost ruins these books for me is the character of Maisie. I find myself rolling my eyes very often at the way the author portrays Maisie. She is obviously very much in love with her creation, and so is every other character in the book! So often characters (and the third-person narrator) describe Maisie as "brave" or "special" that it becomes a bit heavy handed. Show us, don't tell us! Maisie comes off to me as a know-it-all egotist and is condescending to her employee, father, servants, and anyone else who she feels doesn't have her level of intelligence. Speaking of intelligence, Maisie seems to have an almost supernatural or psychic ability. I don't know if this is how the author intended to portray the character, but in all three books many connections are made by "a tingling feeling in the back of Maisie's neck" (paraphrasing), and then suddenly Maisie makes this great cognitive leap, or looks up and another clue is found! It is just too ham-fisted to be believable.
So you may ask, why have you read three of the books if you have all these criticisms? Well, honestly, I don't know. I guess in spite of all of my complaints, these are good books. And I live in hope that Maisie will continue on her fascinating adventures but that the author will get over her girl-crush on her own creation and give me a sympathetic character I can root for!
Back to all reviews by this member
Back to all reviews of this book
Back to Book Reviews
Back to Book Details
Back to all reviews of this book
Back to Book Reviews
Back to Book Details
